Zhuravel, Olga Dmitrievna. Messianism in the ideological constructions of the Old Believers

Zhuravel, Olga Dmitrievna — Dr. Sc. in Philology, Professor, Novosibirsk State University, Novosibirsk, Russia; Senior Researcher, Ural Federal University, Yekaterinburg, Russia, Orc ID 0000-0003-0535-7765, Scopus ID 57194714365, SPIN 1526-5859; e-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

The study was supported by a grant from the Russian Science Foundation (project no. 22-28-01617 «Opposition to the ‟pitch world” in the work of preachers of the late 17^th – early 18^th centuries: author’s axiology, mechanisms of influence».

The article analyzes how several generations of Old Believers’ ideologists perceived the concept of «Moscow, Third Rome». The author argued that at different stages of the history of the Old Believers various aspects of this concept got actualized. At the beginning the Old Believers prioritized the eschatological aspect, then the second generation of the movement’s ideologists found the providential significance of Rus’ as the universal center of Orthodoxy more promising for further discussions. The article examines the reflection of the «Third Rome» doctrine and the complex of ideas associated with it in the literary tradition of the Vyg center of the Old Believers’ movement (the first quarter of the 18^th century). The study is based on the unpublished and yet-to-examined sermons of the leader of the Vyg community, writer, and polemicist Andrey Denisov. His works explored and developed the idea of the Rus’ as the third and last Rome. However A. Denisov did not limit himself to the conclusion of the fall of the «Third Rome», he came further and declared that for now only the Church of Old Believers represented by the Vyg Pustyn remained the last sanctuary of the true faith. A. Denisov created an important mythologem for the Old Believers’ soteriology, claiming the passing on of godliness from the origins of Christianity through the Holy Rus’ to the Old Believers. Since Vyg’s literary school developed on the basis of modern rhetorical strategies, the article demonstrates how it combined ancient traditions of the religious literacy with cultural innovations during the period of transition from Medieval to Modern Times.

Bubnov, Nikolay Yuryevich. Staroobryadcheskaya kniga v Rossii vo vtoroy polovine XVII v.: Istochniki, tipy i evolyuciya [Old Believer book in Russia in the second half of the 17^th century. Sources, types and evolution]. St. Petersburg: Library of the Russian Academy of Sciences Publ., 1995. 435 p. (in Russian).

Crummey, Robert O. The Old Believers and the world of antichrist. The Vyg Community and the Russian State 1694–1855. Madison, Milwaukee and London, 1970. 258 p. 

Fedotov, Georgiy Petrovich. Stihi duhovnye (Russkaya narodnaya vera po duhovnym stiham) [Spiritual verses (Russian folk faith based on spiritual verses)]. Moscow: Progress, Gnozis Publ., 1991. 192 p. (in Russian).

Gol’dberg, Aleksandr L’vovich. Tri «poslaniya Filofeya» (Opyt tekstologicheskogo analiza) [Three «epistles of Philotheus» (Experience of textual analysis)], in Trudy otdela drevnerusskoy literatury. Leningrad: Science Publ., 1974. Vol. 29. Pp. 68–97. (in Russian).

Guryanova, Natalya Sergeevna; Crummey, Robert O. Istoricheskaya shema v sochineniyah pisateley vygovskoy literaturnoy shkoly [The historical scheme in the writings of the writers of the Vyg literary school], in Staroobryadchestvo v Rossii (17–18 vv). Moscow: Arheograficheskiy centr Publ., 1994. Pp. 120–138. (in Russian).

Guryanova, Natalya Sergeevna. Krestyanskiy antimonarhicheskiy protest v staroobryadcheskoy eshatologicheskoy literature perioda pozdnego feodalizma [Peasant anti-monarchist protest in the Old Believer eschatological literature of the period of late feudalism]. Novosibirsk: Science Publ., 1988. 188 p. (in Russian).

Guryanova, Natalya Sergeevna. Staroobryadtsy i tvorcheskoye naslediye Kievskoy mitropolii [Old Believers and the Creative Heritage of the Kyiv Metropolis]. Novosibirsk: Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences Publ., 2007. 379 p. (in Russian).

Ivanov, Aleksandr Ivanovich. Maksim Grek i Savonarola [Maxim Grek and Savonarola], in Trudy otdela drevnerusskoy literatury [Works of the Department of Old Russian Literature]. Vol. 23. Leningrad: Science Publ., 1968. Pp. 117–226. (in Russian).

Korenevskiy, Andrey Vitalyevich. Ideologema otlozhennogo sprosa, ili Skol’ko raz «izobretali» teoriyu «Moskva—Tretiy Rim»? [The ideologeme of pent-up demand, or How many times has the Moscow—Third Rome theory been «invented»?], in Istoricheskiy kuryer. 2021. Vol. 6 (21). Pp. 9–28. (in Russian).

Korenevskiy, Andrey Vitalyevich. Kem i kogda byla «izobretena» teoriya «Moskva–Tretiy Rim»? [Who and when «invented» the theory «Moscow—Third Rome»?], in Ab Imperio. 2001. No 1–2. Pp. 87–124. (in Russian).

Miller, Tatyana Adol’fovna. Mefodiy Olimpskiy i traditsiya platonovskogo dialoga [Methodius of Olympus and the tradition of Platonic dialogue], in Antichnost’ i Vizantiya. Moscow: Science Publ., 1975. Pp. 175–194. (in Russian).

Oparina, Tatyana Anatolyevna. Ivan Nasedka i polemicheskoye bogosloviye kievskoy mitropolii [Ivan Nasedka and the polemical theology of the Kyiv Metropolis]. Novosibirsk: Nauka, Siberian Enterprise of the Russian Academy of Sciences Publ., 1998. 431 p. (in Russian).

Plyuhanova, Mariya Borisovna. Novyy Ierusalim v «italiyskoy pustyni»: Skazaniya o perenesenii doma Bogoroditsy v Loreto [New Jerusalem in the «Italian desert»: Legends about the transfer of the house of the Virgin to Loreto], in Novye Ierusalimy. Ierotopiya i ikonografiya sakral’nyh prostranstv. Moscow: Indrik Publ., 2009. Pp. 419–444. (in Russian).

Sinitsyna, Nina Vasilyevna. Tretiy Rim. Istoki i evolyutsiya srednevekovoy kontseptsii [Third Rome. Origins and evolution of the medieval concept]. Moscow: Indrik Publ., 1998. 416 p. (in Russian).

Titova, Lyubov’ Vasilyevna. Poslaniye dyakona Fedora synu Maksimu — literaturniy i polemicheskiy pamyatnik rannego staroobryadchestva [Deacon Fyodor’s letter to his son Maxim — a literary and polemical monument of the early Old Believers]. Novosibirsk: Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences Publ., 2003. 311 p. (in Russian).

Yuhimenko, Elena Mihaylovna. Literaturnoye naslediye Vygovskogo staroobryadcheskogo obshhezhitel’stva [Literary heritage of the Vyg Old Believer community]. In two volumes. Vol. 1. Moscow: Languages of Slavic cultures Publ., 2008. 688 p. (in Russian).

Yuhimenko, Elena Mihaylovna. Vygovskaya staroobryadcheskaya pustyn’: Dukhovnaya zhizn’ i literature [Old Believers’ desert of Vyg: Spiritual life and literature]. In two volumes. Moscow: Languages of Slavic Culture Publ. Vol. 1. 544 p.; Vol. 2. 480 p. (in Russian).

Zen’kovskiy, Sergey Aleksandrovich. Russkoye staroobryadchestvo [Russian Old Believer]. Vol. 1–2. Moscow: Institut DI-DIK; Kvadriga Publ., 2009. 688 p. (in Russian).

Zen’kovskiy, Sergey Aleksandrovich. Russkoye staroobryadchestvo: Duhovnye dvizheniya semnadcatogo veka [Russian Old Believers: Spiritual movements of the seventeenth century]. Reprint. Moscow: Tserkov’ Publ., 1995. 528 p. (in Russian).

Zenkovsky, Sergey Aleksandrovich. The ideological World of the Denisov Brothers, in Harvard Slavic Studies. 1957. Vol. III. Pp. 49–66.

Zhuravel’, Ol’ga Dmitrievna. Literaturnoye tvorchestvo staroobryadtsev XVIII – nachala XXI vv.: Temy, problemy, poetika [Literary creativity of the Old Believers 18^th – early 21^th centuries: Themes, problems, poetics]. Novosibirsk: Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences Publ., 2012. 442 p. (in Russian).

Zhurova, Lyudmila Ivanovna. Avtorskiy tekst Maksima Greka: Rukopisnaya i literaturnaya traditsii [The author’s text of Maxim Grek: Handwritten and literary traditionsions]. Part 2. Compositions. Novosibirsk: Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences Publ., 2011. 302 p. (in Russian).