Matveev G. F. On the issue of nations right to self determination in the First World War

Modified Date
Published Date:
Title of the article On the history of the right of nations to self-determination in the First World War
Authors Matveev, Gennadiy Filippovich – Doctor of Historical Sciences, full professor, Head of the Slavic Studies Department, Faculty of History, Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
In the section In memoriam / In Memory
Year 2014 Issue 1 Pages 171-193
Type of article RAR Index UDK 94(100)"1914/19" Index BBK 63.3 (0) 61
Abstract The article analyzes the evolution of the views of the leaders of the Great Powers on the role and place of the national question in international politics and international law during the years of the First World War. The author argues that neither the leadership of the Entente nor of the Central Powers had a full understanding of problems of the oppressed European nations before 1916. The issue was mostly perceived as the collection of particular individual problems: Polish, Czech, Serbian, Macedonian, Ukrainian, Finnish, Lithuanian, Latvian, Estonian, Irish, Flemish, and others. Both belligerent coalitions saw the Polish Question as having for Russia, Austro-Hungary, and Germany, not only an international significance as well as a domestic dimension. The turning point in the approach to the national issue dates back to late 1916 – early 1917. The establishment of the Polish Kingdom by Berlin and Vienna in November 1916 had two important consequences. First, by resorting to concrete actions regarding the Polish Question that was of local significance, two powers gave the green light to transforming the slogan advocated by the leftists about the right of nations to self-determination into a norm of international law. Even the limited implementation of that norm in 1918–1919 resulted in the disintegration of Austria-Hungary and in Germany’s first territorial losses in the 20th century. Second, one of the fundamental norms of international law was violated. According to that norm the treaties on borders had never been abrogated, but suspended for the duration of the conflict between the parties concerned. Nicholas II promised to unite all Polish lands in the Russian Empire with the right of autonomy. The Entente and the USA stated their support of the declaration in a way that could also be interpreted as a general acknowledgement of the right of nations to determine their own destiny. It was precisely this general discourse that encouraged the political elites of the stateless nations. They construed it as the Great Powers’ readiness to implement the right of nations to self-determination. Also, the author emphasizes that in reality this principle was making its first steps in the world politics, was applied to a limited number of dependent nations. By the same token, the Wilson Peace Program had a strictly selective application in determining the nations that would be guaranteed the right to self-determination.
Keywords right of nations to self-determination, First World War, Wilson Peace Program
Full text version of the article. Article language Russian
Bibliography
  • Backer, Ray Stannard (ed.). Woodrow Wilson. Kształtowanie losów świata: pamiętniki i dokumenty[Woodrow Wilson.Forming the world’s destiny. Memoirs and documents].T. I / Wydał; autoryzowany przekładAndrzeja Tretiaka i Teresy Świderskiej. Warszawa: Instytut «Biblioteka Polska» Publ., 1924. 382 s. (in Polish.)

    Beneš, Edvard. Smysl československe revoluce[The meaning of the Czechoslovak revolution]. Praha: Památník Odboje Publ., 1923. 74 s. (in Czech.)

    Filasiewicz, Stanislas. La question polonaise pendantla guerre mondial [Polish Question during the World War]. Paris: Section d’etudes et de publications politiques du Comite National Polonais Publ., 1920. 590 p. (in French.)

    Hummerus, Herman. Ukraina v perelomni chasi. Shist’ misyatsiv na choli posol’stva v Kievi [Ukraine in critical time. At the head of Embassy in Kiev for six months]. Kyiv: Takson Publ., 1997. 194 p. (in Ukrainian.)

    Kumaniecki, Kazimierz Władysław. Odbudowa państwowości polskiej. Najważniejsze dokumenty. 1912 – styczeń 1924.[Restoration of the Polish Statehood. Most important documents. 1912 – January 1924]. Warszawa; Kraków: Nakładem księgarni J. Czerneckiego Publ., 1924. 782 s. (in Polish.)

    Lloyd George,David. Pravda o mirnykh dogovorakh[The Truth About the Peace Treaties].Т. I. Moscow: Innostrannoy literatury Publ., 1957. 654 с. (in Russian.)

    Lloyd George,David. Voennye memuary [War Memoirs]. Moscow: Sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoe gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo Publ., 1935. Т. III. 446 p. (in Russian.)

    Lloyd George,David. Voennye memuary [War Memoirs]. Moscow: Sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoe gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo Publ., 1935.Т. IV. 443 p. (in Russian.)

    Lloyd George,David. Voennye memuary [War Memoirs]. Moscow: Sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoe gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo Publ., 1938. Т.V. 366 p. (in Russian.)

    Ludendorff, Erich. Moi vospominaniya o voyne 19141918 gg. [My memories of the war 1914–1918]. Т. 1. Moscow: Sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoe gosudarstvennoe Publ., 1923. 456 p. (in Russian.)

    Masaryk, Tomáš Garrigue. Světová revoluce: za války a ve válce. 19141918. [The World Revolution: during the war and at the war. 1914-1918]. Praha: Čin a Orbis Publ., 1925. 650 s. (in Czech.)

    Matveev, Gennadiy Filippovich. Fevral’skaya revolyutsiya i pol’skiy vopros [February Revolution and Polish Question], in Revolyutsionnaya Rossiya 1917 goda i pol’skiy vopros: novye istochniki, novye vzglyady. Moscow: Institut slavyanovedeniya RAN Publ., 2009. P. 85–92. (in Russian.)

    Matveev, Gennadiy Filippovich. Nachalo [Beginning], in Belye pyatna — chernye pyatna. Slozhnye voprosy v rossiysko-pol’skikh otnosheniyakh. Moscow: «Aspekt Press» Publ., 2010. P. 15–50. (in Russian.)

    Matveev, Gennadiy Filippovich. Początki [Beginning], in Białe plamy — czarne plamy. Sprawy trudne w polsko-rosyjskich stosunkach 1918–2008. Warszawa: Polski Instytut Spraw Międzynarodowych Publ., 2010. S. 45–81.(in Polish.)

    Sokolnicki, Michał. Polska w pamiętnikach Wielkiej wojny. 1914–1918. [Poland in the memoirs of the GreatWar]. Warszawa: Instytut Wydawniczy «Bibljoteka Polska» Publ., 1925. 678 s. (in Polish.)

    Stanković, Đorđe. Nikola Pašić, saveznici i stvaranje Jugoslavije [Nikola Pašić, the allies and the making of Yugoslavia]. Zaječar: Zadužbina Nikole Pašića Publ., 1995. 282 p. (in Ukrainian.)

    Tardieu, André. Mir [Peace]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat Publ., 1943. 654 p. (in Russian.)

    Winiarski, Bohdan. Międzynarodowość sprawy polskiej [Internationalism of the Polish cause]. Piotrogród: Polski Komitet Narodowy Publ., 1917. 71 s. (in Polish.)

 

Tags: Wilson Peace Program, First World War, right of nations to self-determination, In Memoriam / In Memory