Popović, Mihailo St.; Zervan, Vratislav. The «Fatherland» of the Serbian Kings Milutin and Dečanski or Some Additional Thoughts on the «Medieval Serbian Oecumene»

Published Date:

For citation: Popović, Mihailo St.; Zervan, Vratislav. The «Fatherland» of the Serbian Kings Milutin and Dečanski or Some Additional Thoughts on the «Medieval Serbian Oecumene», in Studia Slavica et Balcanica Petropolitana. 2022. № 1. Pp. 36-57. DOI https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu19.2022.102

Title of the article The «Fatherland» of the Serbian Kings Milutin and Dečanski or Some Additional Thoughts on the «Medieval Serbian Oecumene»
Authors

Popović, Mihailo St. ― Dr. Habilitation, Division of Byzantine Research, Institute for Medieval Research, Austrian Academy of Sciences, Vienna, Austria, Orс ID 0000-0002-3128-2210; e-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.;
Zervan, Vratislav ― PhD in History, Division of Byzantine Research, Institute for Medieval Research, Austrian Academy of Sciences, Vienna, Austria, Orc ID 0000-0002-1870-4482; e-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

In the section  Disputatio / Discussion
Year 2022 Issue 1 Pages 36-57
Type of article RAR Index UDK; BBK UDK 930.85; BBK 63.3(4) Index DOI  https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu19.2022.102
Abstract

This article derives from scholarly results achieved within the FWF — Austrian Science Fund project entitled «Byzantino-Serbian Border Zones in Transition: Migration and Elite Change in pre-Ottoman Macedonia (1282–1355)» (FWF Austrian Science Fund, project P 30384-G28).

Mihailo St. Popović, in his part of the Study, follows up on the premise that an own local concept of ecumene was emerging during the reigns of Stefan Uroš II Milutin and Stefan Uroš III Dečanski. In his analysis, he relies on Serbian medieval charters and inscription. Following the analysis of the charter of Serbian King Stefan Uroš II Milutin for the Ulijare settlement, he recognizes the clear antithesis between the fatherland and the Serbian Land of the Serbian King on one hand, and Great Romania and the Greek Empire of the Byzantine Emperor, on the other. According to him, the narrative part of the manuscript clearly proves that it is not possible to notice the concept of universality in Milutin’s politics. Inspired by the research of Paul Nick Kardulias, he considers the Kingdom of Serbia as a self-contained space. With an emphasis on the examination of the charters and inscriptions, he states that during the reign of Milutin, such a space was probably created. From the World System Analysis perspective, charters and inscriptions from the reign of Stefan Uroš III Dečanski paint a slightly different picture. They probably illustrate the transition from selfcontained space to the great realm. In his part of the study, Vratislav Zevran focused mainly on the semantic level of the use of Slavic pendants of the Greek word οἰκουμένη and expressions otьčьstvije and otьčьstvo. The most common equivalent of the word οἰκουμένη was the loan translation vъseljenaja. By analyzing the use of the adjective derivative vьseljenьskyi in connection with the Byzantine common titles, he finds that the idea of universality prevailed only in the titles of general councils, and the only Byzantine Emperor thusly named was Andronikos II. Although he does not recognize the use of the adjective derivative vьseljenьskyi anywhere near the Serbian monarch, he believes that based on several examples, Serbian panegyric probably promoted the idea of a Serbian ruler who was also vьseljenьskyi. The key concept of a fatherland still lacks a comprehensive analysis of sources. Two forms otьčьstvije and otьčьstvo have settled in Church Slavonic. Over time, the ambivalence of both forms merged into a concept that implied the meaning of «family», «genus» and/or «generation». At the same time, they were joined by the attributes «royal» or «rulers», which indeed emerged on the basis of the word otьcь and worked with the meaning of the authority and power of the father. This concept then also appears in the hagiographic work of Danilo and his disciple.

Keywords Byzantium, Byzantine Commonwealth, Balkans, Serbia, Middle Ages, Oecumene, Fatherland, Byzantium, cultural studies, medieval studies
Full text version of the article Article language  English
Bibliography

Angelov, Dimitr. Blgarsko srednovkovie ― Ideologichna misl i prosveta [The Bulgarian Middle Ages —Ideological Thought and Enlightment]. Sofia: Narodna Prosveta Publ., 1982. 166 p. (in Bulgarian).
Angelov, Dimiter. Imperial Ideology and Political Thought in Byzantium, 1204–1330. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007. 453 p.
Christians, Dagmar (ed.). Die Serbische Alexandreis nach der Sofioter Handschrift. Nr. 771. Text und Übersetzung mit wissenschaftlichem Apparat, Stellenkommentar, Glossar und einer Einführung. Mit einem Beitrag zu griechischen Texten von Erich Trapp. Köln; Weimar; Wien: Böhlau Publ., 1991. (Bausteine zur Slavischen Philologie und Kulturgeschichte. Reihe B: Editionen. Neue Folge 2 (17)). 530 p. (in German).
Ćirković, Sima. Biografiya kralya Milutina u Ulyarskoy povelyi [Biography of the King Milutin in the Ulijarska charter], in Đurić, Voјislav Ј. (ed.). Arkhiepiskop Danilo i nyegovo doba. Belgrade: Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts Press, 1991. (Nauchni skupovi. Vol. 58. Odelyenye istoriјskikh nauka. Vol. 17). Pp. 53–68. (in Serbian).
Ćirković, Sima (ed.). Istoriya srpskog naroda. Kn. 1: Od naystariyikh vremena do Marichke bitke (1371) [History of the Serbian Nation. Vol. I: From the Earliest Times to the Battle of Maritsa (1371)]. Belgrade: Srpska knizhevna zadruga Publ., 1981. 697 p. (in Serbian).
Detrez, Raymond. Ethnic Consciousness in Rural and Urban Enviroments. The Case of Plovdiv and the Plovdiv Region, in Rudić, Srđan; Ćaldović-Šijaković, Svetlana (eds). Selo Balkana. Kontinueti i promene kroz istoriyu. Belgrade: Institute of History Belgrade Press; Muzeј na otvorenom «Staro selo» Sirogoјno Publ., 2017. (Zbornik radova. Vol. 34). Pp. 11–21.
Gaul, Niels. All the Emperor’s Men (and His Nephews): Paideia and Networking Strategies at the Court of Andronikos II Palaiologos, 1290–1320, in Dumbarton Oaks Papers. 2016. Vol. 70. Pp. 245–270.
Grivec, France. Vselenskiy ― soborniy, in Slavistichna reviya. 1957. No. 10. Pp. 14–34. (in Slovenian).
Hafner, Stanislaus (ed.). Serbisches Mittelalter. Altserbische Herrscherbiographien. Bd 2: Danilo II. und seine Schüler. Die Königsbiographien. Graz; Wien; Köln: Styria Publ., 1976. 336 p. (in German).
Hafner, Stanislaus. Studien zur altserbischen dynastischen Historiographie. München: R. Olderbourg Publ., 1964. 141 p. (in German).
Hall, Thomas D.; Kardulias, Paul Nick; Chase-Dunn, Christopher. World-Systems Analysis and Archaeology: Continuing the Dialogue, in Journal of Archaeological Research. 2011. Vol. 19/3. Pp. 233–279.
Ivanov, Jordan. Blgarski starini iz Makedoniya [Bulgarian Antiquities from Macedonia]. (Phototype edition: Sofia: Drzhavna pechatnitsa Publ., 1931). Sofia: Nauka i izkustvo Publ., 1970. 703 p. (in Bulgarian).
Ječmenica, Dejan. Prva Stonska povelya kralya Stefana Dushana [The first charter of the King Stefan Dušan concerning the town of Ston], in Stari srpski arkhiv. 2010. Vol. 9. Pp. 25–50. (in Serbian).
Jouanno, Corinne. Byzantine Views on Alexander the Great, in Moore, Kenneth R. (ed.). Brill’s Companion to the Reception of Alexander the Great. Leiden; Boston: Brill Publ., 2018. (Brill’s Companions to the Classical Reception. Vol. 14). Pp. 449–476.
Kaltsogianni, Eleni. Die Lobrede des Matthaios von Ephesos auf Andronikos II. Palaiologos, in Jahrbuch der Österreichischen Byzantinistik. 2010. Vol. 59. Pp. 107–127. (in German).
Kaltsogianni, Eleni. Nikephoros Xanthopoulos und die Kaiserpanegyrik: Das Bild Kaiser Andronikos II. in der Dedicatio der Historia ecclesiastica und seine literarischen Vorbilder, in Gastgeber, Christian; Panteghini, Sebastiano (eds). Ecclesiastical history and Nikephoros Kallistou Xanthopoulos: Proceedings of the International Symposium. Vienna, 15th–16th December 2011. Wien: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften Publ., 2015. Pp. 109–124. (in German).
Kardulias, Paul Nick; Hall, Thomas D. Archaeology and World-Systems Analysis, in World Archaeology. 2008. Vol. 40/4. Pp. 572–583.
Kyriakidis, Savvas. Warfare and propaganda: The portrayal of Andronikos II Palaiologos (1282–1328) as an incompetent military leader in the Histories of John VI Kantakouzenos (1347–54), in Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies. 2013. Vol. 37. Pp. 176–189.
Laiou, Angeliki E. Constantinople and the Latins. The Foreign Policy of Andronicus II. 1282–1328. Cambridge (Massachusetts): Harvard University Press, 1972. 388 p.
Maksimović, Ljubomir. Znachenye rechi Grk i Yelin u srpskim srednyovekovnim izvorima [The Meaning of the Words Grk i Jelin in Serbian Medieval Sources], in Zbornik radova Vizantoloshkog instituta. 1999/2000. Vol. 38. Pp. 215–227. (in Serbian).
Marjanović-Dušanić, Smilja. O pitanyu autentichnosti povelya Mrachkog kompleksa [On the Question of the Authenticity of the Mraka Complex Charter], in Stari srpski arkhiv. 2004. Vol. 3. Pp. 153–168. (in Serbian).
Mišić, Siniša. Povelya kralya Stefana Urosha III manastiru Svetog Nikole Mrachkog u Orekhovu [The Charter of King Stefan Uroš III for the Monastery of Saint Nikola Mrački in Orehovo], in Stari srpski arkhiv. 2002. Vol. 1. Pp. 55–68. (in Serbian).
Mortimer, Ian. The Time Traveler’s Guide to Elizabethan England. New York: Penguin Books Publ., 2014. 393 p.
Nicol, Donald M. The Byzantine Lady: Ten portraits: 1250–1500. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994. 143 p.
Pavlikianov, Cyril. The Mediaeval Greek and Bulgarian Documents of the Athonite Monastery of Zographou (980–1600). Critical Edition and Commentary of the Texts. Sofia: St. Kliment Ohridski University Press, 2014. (Universitska biblioteka, 512). 911 p.
Pavlović, Bojana. Der serbische Alexanderroman zwischen Byzanz und dem Abendland: Die Frage der kulturellen Einflüße, in Juhász, Erika (ed.). Byzanz und das Abendland II. Studia Byzantino-Occidentalia. Budapest: Eötvös-József-Collegium Publ., 2014. Pp. 97–118. (in German).
Piltz, Elisabeth. King (kralj) Milutin and the Paleologan tradition, in Byzantinoslavica. 2011. Vol. 69. Pp. 173–188.
Popović, Mihailo St. Historische Geographie und Digital Humanities. Eine Fallstudie zum spätbyzantinischen und osmanischen Makedonien. Mainz; Ruhpolding: Franz Philipp Rutzen Publ., 2014. (Peleus, Studien zur Archäologie und Geschichte Griechenlands und Zyperns. Bd 61). 216 p. (in German).
Popović, Mihailo St. The «Medieval Serbian Oecumene» — Fiction or Reality? in Bikić, Vesna (ed.). Byzantine Heritage and Serbian Art I. Process of Byzantinisation and Serbian Archaeology. Belgrade: The Serbian National Comittee of Byzantine Studies Press; P. E. Službeni Glasnik; Institute for Byzantine Studies, Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts Press, 2016. Pp. 37–43.
Popović, Mihailo St.; Zervan, Vratislav; Filiposki, Toni. Über das Verhältnis von Herrschertiteln und Räumen: Eine Fallstudie zu Makedonien unter dem König und Zaren Stefan Dušan (1331–1355), in Zbornik radova Vizantoloshkog instituta. 2020. Vol. 57. Pp. 61–102. (in German).
Ređep, Jelka. Aleksandar Veliki i kral’ Milutin. Srpska Aleksandrida i Danilov zbornik — paralela [Alexander the Great and the king Milutin. Serbian Alexandriad and the collection of Danilo — parallel], in Zbornik Matitse srpske za knizhevnost i yezik. 1999. Vol. 47. Pp. 19–34. (in Serbian).
Roux, Jean Paul. Kral. Myty a symboly. Z francouzskeho originalu Le roi. [The King: Myths and Symbols. From the French original Le roi]. Prague: Argo Publ., 2009. 360 p. (in Czech).
Savić, Viktor. (Pseudo)klasichni i stari nazivi srpskikh zemalya u starim srpskim izvorima [(Pseudo)classical and Old Names of Serbian Lands in Old Serbian Sources], in Stojanović, Jelica (ed.). Srpsko yezichko i knizhevno naslyedzhe na prostoru danashnye Tsrne Gore. Srpski yezik i knizhevnost danas. Zbornik radova sa Drugog medzhunarodnog nauchnog skupa odrzhanog u Podgoritsi 26–28. maјa 2017. Podgorica; Novi Sad; Banja Luka: Matica srpska Publ.; Društvo članova u Crnoj Gori Publ., 2019, 2019. Pp. 95–125. (in Serbian).
Sindik, Dušan I. Srpska srednyovekovna akta u manastiru Khilandaru [The Serbian Medieval Charters in the Hilandar Monastery], in Khilandarski zbornik. 1998. Vol. 10. Pp. 9–132. (in Serbian).
Schneider, Jean. Le moine et l’empereur Andronic II dans les lettres de Maxime Planude, in Bernard-Valette, Clementine; Delmulle, Jeremy; Gerzaguet, Camille (eds). Nihil veritas erubescit. Mélanges offerts à Paul Mattei par ses élèves, collègues et amis. Turnhout: Brepols Publ., 2017. Pp. 655–669. (in French).
Schumann, Kurt. Die griechischen Lehnbildungen und Lehnbedeutungen im Altbulgarischen. Berlin; Wiesbaden: Harrasowitz Publ., 1958. (Veröffentlichungen der Abteilung für Slavische Sprachen und Literaturen des Osteuropa-Instituts der Freien Universität Berlin. Bd 16). 66 p. (in German).
Škrivanić, Gavro A. Bitka kod Velbuzhda 28. VII 1330. godine [Battle of Velbužd on 28. VII. of the year 1330], in Vesnik Vojnog muzeja. 1970. Vol. 16. Pp. 67–77. (in Serbo-Croatian).
Stojanović, Ljubomir (ed.). Stari srpski zapisi i natpisi [Old Serbian Records and Inscriptions]. Vol. I. Belgrade: Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts Press; National Library of Serbia Publ.; Novi Sad: Matica Srpska Publ., 1982. (Phototype edition 4). 480 p. (in Serbian).
Subotin-Golubović, Tatjana. Yosh o «Zhitiyu u svitku» kralya Milutina [More about the «Scrolled Vita» of King Milutin], in Zbornik radova Vizantoloshkog instituta. 1994. Vol. 33. Pp. 115–125. (in Serbian).
Treadgold, Warren. Marjanović, Dragoljub. Creating Memories in Late 8th -century Byzantium. The Short History of Nikephoros of Constantinople. Central European Medieval Studies, in The Medieval Review. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, 2018. P. 250.
Ubiparip, Milanka. Zbornik sa kratkim zhitiyem kralya Milutina [A Collection with a Short Biography of King Milutin], in Prilozi za knizhevnost, yezik, istoriyu i folklor. 2005. Vol. 71/1–4. Pp. 53–72. (in Serbian).
Uzelac, Aleksandar. Atlamish ― kumanski tsar iz srpske Aleksandride [Atlamiš ― The Cuman ruler from the Serbian Alexandriad], in Cvijanović, Irena R.; Rudić, Srđan (eds). Spomenitsa Dr. Tibora Zhivkovića. Belgrade: Institute of History Belgrade Press, 2016. (Zbornik radova. Vol. 32). Pp. 221–228. (in Serbian).
Veselinović, Andrija. Osnivachka povelya kralya Milutina za Khilandarski pirg na moru sa Khramom Spasovim [The Founding Charter of the King Milutin for the Hilandar Tower with the Savior’s Church], in Stari srpski arkhiv. 2010. Vol. 9. Pp. 19–24. (in Serbian).
Vujošević, Žarko Z. Srpska vladarska kantselariјa u srednem veku. Studiya iz uporedne diplomatike. Doktorska disertatsiya [The Serbian Royal Chancery in the Middle Ages. A Study in Comparative Diplomatics. Thesis for a PhD degree]. Belgrade: University of Belgrade, Faculty of Philosophy Press, 2015. 333 p. (in Serbian).
Živojinović, Dragić. Velika prilepska khrisovulya tsara Stefana Dushana Kareyskoy keliyi svetog Save (Khil. 149) [The grand chrysobull of the Emperor Stefan Dušan for the Kareys cell of the Saint Sava issued at Prilep (Hil. 149)], in Stari srpski arkhiv. 2008. Vol. 7. Pp. 71–90. (in Serbian).

Tags: Vizantium cultural influence, medieval studies, Byzantium, Serbia, Byzantine studies, DISPUTATIO / DISCUSSION, Balkans, medieval Russian culture, cultural studies

  • Hits: 111