Curta F. The making slavs between ethnogenesis, invention, and migration

Modified Date
Published Date:
Title of the article  The making slavs between ethnogenesis, invention, and migration
Authors  Curta F. - The University of Florida (USA)
In the section  Commentarii / Articles
Year 2008 Issue  2 Pages  155-172
Type of article RAR Index UDK  391/395+903(-161.1)+ 94(495).01 Index BBK  
Abstract  The author gives in this paper a detailed commentary to the papers by S. Ivanov, P. Shuvalov, P. Barford, A. Pleterski, D. Dzino, D. Polyviannyi, B. Todorov, I. Muzic, D. Alimov and A. Klibin' in a context of the problem of the making of Slavic ethnicity.
Keywords Ethnogenesis of slaves, Balkans, archeology of slaves
Full text version of the article Article language  english
Bibliography

1. Duncan G. L. Coin Circulation in the Danubian and Balkan Provinces of the Roman Empire AD 294-578. London, 1993.
2. Curta F. Invasion or Inflation? Sixth-to Seventh-century Byzantine Coin Hoards in Eastern and Southeastern Europe//Annali dell'Istituto Italiano di Numismatica. 1996. Vol. 43. P. 65-224.
3. Шувалов П. В. Случайные флуктуации или преднамеренный отбор? (Три клада фолисов последней четверти VI в.) // Stratum plus. 1999. № 6. С. 104-110.
4. Mirnik Prezelj I. Re-thinking ethnicity in archaeology//Slovenija in sosednje deюele med antiko in karolinрko dobo. Zaиetki slovenske etnogeneze/Ed. by R. Brato., H.-D. Kahl. Ljubljana, 2000. S. 581-603.
5. Profantovб N. Kulturnн diskontinuita a mo.nosti jejн interpretace jako etnickй zmмny (problйm tzv. slovanskй expanze): Problйm symbolickйho systйmu sebeidentifikace elity a jeho nedustateиnйho poznбnн // Archaeologia historica. 2003. Vol. 28. S. 19-31.
6. Barford P. M. Identity and material culture. Did the early Slavs follow the rules or did they make up their own?//East Central Europe/L'Europe du Centre-Est. 2004. Vol. 31. Part 1. P. 77-123.
7. Pohl W. Die Namen der Barbaren: Fremdbezeichnung und Identitдt in Spдtantike und Frьhmittelalter//Zentrum und Peripherie -gesellschaftliche Phдnomene in der Frьhgeschichte: Materialien des 13. internationalen Symposiums «Grundprobleme der frьhgeschichtlichen Entwicklung im mittleren Donauraum», Zwettl, 4.-8. Dezember 2000/Hrsg. von H. Friesinger und A. Stuppner. Wien, 2004. S. 95-104.
8. Васильев М. А. Анты, словене, немцы, греки: Славянский культурно-лингвистический мир и его соседи в раннесредневековое время//Славяноведение. 2005. № 2. С. 3-19.
9. Bálint Cs. Az ethnos a kora középkorban (a kutatás lehetőségei és korlátai)//Századok. 2006. Évf. 2. O. 1-70.
10. Tabaczyсski S. Procesy etnogenetyczne jako problem badawczy archeologii//Archeologia o poczаtkach sщowian: Materiaщy z konferencji, Krakуw 19-21 listopada 2001/Red. P. Kaczanowski, M. Parczewski. Krakуw, 2005. S. 37-50.
11. Härke H. Ethnicity, «Race» and Migration in Mortuary Archaeology: An Attempt at a Short Answer//Anglo-Saxon Studies in Archaeology and History. 2007. Vol. 14. P. 11-18.
12. Gillett A. Ethnogenesis: A Contested Model of Early Medieval Europe//History Compass. 2006. Vol. 4. Nr 2. P. 241-260.
13. Goffart W. Jordanes' Getica and the Disputed Authenticity of Gothic Origins from Scandinavia//Speculum. 2005. Vol. 80. P. 379-398.
14. Kaldellis A. Procopius of Caesarea. Tyranny, History, and Philosophy at the End of Antiquity. Philadelphia, 2004.
15. Brodka D. Die Geschichtsphilosophie in der spдtantiken Historiographie. Studien zu Prokopios von Kaisareia, Agathias von Myrina und Theophylaktos Simokattes. Frankfurt a. M.; Berlin; Bern; New York, 2004.
16. Revanoglou E. M. Geographika kai ethnographika stoicheia sto ergo tou Prokopiou Kaisareias. Thessaloniki, 2005.
17. Dunn A. W. Was there a militarisation of the southern Balkans during Late Antiquity?//Limes XVIII. Proceedings of the XVIIIth International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies/Ed. by P. Freeman. Oxford, 2002. P. 705-712.
18. Curta F. Frontier Ethnogenesis in Late Antiquity: The Danube, the Tervingi, and the Slavs//Borders, Barriers, and Ethnogenesis: Frontiers in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages/Ed. by F. Curta. Turnhout, 2005. P. 173-204.
Контекст: ...P. 705-712; Curta F. Frontier Ethnogenesis in Late Antiquity: The Danube, the Tervingi, and the Slavs // Borders, Barriers, and Ethnogenesis: Frontiers in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages / Ed. by F. Curta. Turnhout, 2005...

19. Kirilov Ch. The Reduction of the Fortified City Area in Late Antiquity: Some Reflections on the End of the «Antique City» in the Lands of the Eastern Roman Empire//Post-Roman Towns, Trade, and Settlement in Europe and Byzantium/Ed. by J. Henning. Berlin; New York, 2007. P. 3-24.
20. Thomason S. G. Language Contact: An Introduction. Washington, 2001.
21. Townend M. Language and History in Viking-age England: Linguistic Relations Between Speakers of Old Norse and Old English. Turnhout, 2002.
22. Curta F. The Slavic lingua franca (Linguistic Notes of an Archaeologist Turned Historian)//East Central Europe/L'Europe du Centre-Est. 2004. Vol. 31. Part 1. P. 125-148.
23. Pritsak O. The Slavs and the Avars//Gli Slavi occidentali e meridionali nell'alto Medioevo. Spoleto, 1983. P. 353-435.
24. Lunt H. G. On Common Slavic//Зборник Матице српске за филологиjу и лингвистику. Нови Сад, 1984-1985. К. XXVII-XXVIII. C. 417-422.
25. Lunt H. G. Slavs, Common Slavic, and Old Church Slavonic//Litterae Slavicae Medii Aevi. Francisco Venceslao Mares Sexagenario Oblatae/Hrsg. von J. Reinhart. Mьnchen, 1985. S. 185-204.
26. Nichols J. The linguistic geography of the Slavic expansion//American Contributions to the Eleventh International Congress of Slavists. Bratislava, August-September 1993. Literature, Linguistics, Poetics/Ed. by R. A. Maguire and A. Timberlake. Columbus, Ohio, 1993. P. 377-391.
27. Parczewski M. Praojczyzna Siowian w ujњciu кrуdioznawczym//Cieс Љwiatowita czyli piж№ giosуw w sprawie etnogenezy Siowian/Red. A. Kokowski. Lublin, 2002. S. 22-68.
28. Parczewski M. Remarks on the Discussion of Polish Archaeologists on the Ethnogenesis of Slavs//Archaeologia Lituana. 2003. Vol. 4. S. 138-142.
29. Kaczanowski P. Uwagi do stanu badaс nad zagadnieniem praojczyzny Siowian//Archeologia o pocz№tkach Siowian: Materiaiy z konferencji, Krakуw, 19-21 listopada 2001/Red. P. Kaczanowski, M. Parczewski. Krakуw, 2005. S. 13-18.
30. Makiewicz T. W sprawie aktualnego stanu badaс nad problemem kontynuacji kulturowej pomiжdzy staroэytnoъciа a wczesnym ъredniowieczem w Polsce. Punkt widzenia autochtonisty // SA. 2005. T. 46. S. 9-38.
31. Barford P. M. Crisis in the Shadows: Recent Polish Polemic on the Origin of the Slavs//SA. 2003. T. 44. S. 121-155.
32. Goffart W. Barbarian Tides: The Migration Age and the Later Roman Empire. Philadelphia, 2006.
33. Petkov K. The Voices of Medieval Bulgaria, Seventh-Fifteenth Century: The Records of a Bygone Culture. Leiden; Boston, 2008. P. 8.
34. Constantine of Preslav, Alphabetical Prayer//Куев K. M. Азбучната молитва в славянските литератури. София, 1974. С. 170-174
35. Petkov K. The Voices of Medieval Bulgaria... P. 60.
36. Иванов Й. Български старини из Македония. София, 1970. С. 147-150
37. Petkov K. The Voices of Medieval Bulgaria... P. 62.
38. Matijeviг-Sokol M., Sokol V. Hrvatska i Nin u doba kneza Branimira. II. izdanje. Zagreb, 2005. S. 35-57.
39. Delonga V. Latinski epigrafiиki spomenici u ranosrednjovjekovnoj Hrvatskoj. Split, 1996. S. 207-208.
40. Rapaniг Ю. Biljeрke uz иetiri Branimirova natpisa//SHP. Split, 1981. Ser. III. Sv. 11.
41. Margetiг L. Branimirov natpis iz 888. godine i meрunarodni polo.aj Hrvatske//Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Zagrebu. 1990. Sv. 40. Br. 1. S. 5-16.
42. Zekan M. Pet natpisa kneza Branimira s posebnim osvrtom na nalaz iz Otresa//Kaиiг: Zbornik Franjevaиke provincije Presvetoga Otkupitelja. 1993. Sv. 25. S. 405-420.
43. Delonga V. Latinski epigrafiиki spomenici... S. 166-167.
44. Lambot C. Oeuvres thйologiques et grammaticales de Godescals d'Orbais. Louvain, 1945. P. 169.
45. Fine J. V. A. Croats and Slavs: theories about the historical circumstances of the Croats' appearance in the Balkans//BF. 2000. Bd 26. S. 211
46. Curta F. The Making of the Slavs: History and Archaeology of the Lower Danube Region, c. 500-700. Cambridge; New York, 2001. P. 350
47. American Slavic Studies. 2004. Vol. 38. Nr 3. P. 337-338.
48. Delonga V. Latinski epigrafiиki spomenici... S. 207.
49. Delonga V. Latinski epigrafiиki spomenici... S. 217-218.
50. Curta F. Southeastern Europe in the Middle Ages, 500-1250. Cambridge; New York, 2006. P. 139-141.
51. Matijeviг-Sokol M., Sokol V. Hrvatska i Nin... S. 70.
52. Полывянный Д. И. Культурное своеобразие средневековой Болгарии в контексте византийско-славянской общности. Иваново, 2000.
53. Полывянный Д. И. Византийско-славянская общность в представлениях болгар X-XIV вв.//Славяне и их соседи: Греческий и славянский мир в Средние века и раннее Новое время: Сб. статей к 70-летию акад. Геннадия Григорьевича Литаврина/Под ред. Б. Н. Флори, Е. М. Ломидзе, Н. С. Захарьиной. М., 1996. С. 100-108.
54. Lunt H. G. What the Rus' Primary Chronicle Tells us About the Origin of the Slavs and of Slavic Writing//HUS. 1995. Vol. 19. P. 335.
55. Avenarius A. Zaиiatky slovanov na strednom Dunaji: autochtonistickб teуria vo svetle sъиasnйho badania//HИ. 1992. Roи. 40. И. 1. S. 1-16.
56. Tolochko O. P. The Primary Chronicle.s «Ethnography» Revisited: Slavs and Varangians in the Middle Dnieper Region and the Origin of the Rus. State//Franks, Northmen, and Slavs. Identities and State Formation in Early Medieval Europe/Ed. by I. H. Garipzanov, P. J. Geary, P. Urbaсczyk. Turnhout, 2008. P. 178.
57. Curta F. The Making of the Slavs... P. 350.
58. Darden B. J. Who were the Sclaveni and where did they come from?//BF. 2004. Bd 28. S. 135-137
59. Schenker A. M. Were there Slavs in Central Europe before the Great Migration?//International Journal of Slavic Linguistics and Poetics. 1985. Vol. 31-32. P. 359-374.
60. Popowska-Taborska H. Wczesne dzieje Siowian w ъwietle ich jкzyka. Wrociaw, 1991.
61. Curta F. The Making of the Slavs... P. 346.
62. Theophylact Simocatta. History 6-2, 10-15: Theophylacti Simocattae. Historia/Ed. C. de Boor; Re-ed. P. Wirth. Stuttgart, 1972. P. 223-224.
63. The History of Theophylact Simocatta/Engl. transl. by Mary and Michael Whitby. Oxford, 1986. P. 160-161..
64. Kollautz A. Die Idealisierung der Slawen bei Theophylakt als Beispiel seiner ethnographischer Darstellungsweise//Rapports du III-e Congrès international d'archéologie slave. Bratislava, 7-14 septembre 1975/Ed. by B. Chropovský. Vol. 2. Bratislava, 1980. P. 189-204
65. Dulinicz M. Frühe Slawen im Gebiet zwischen unterer Weichsel und Elbe. Eine archäologische Studie. Neumünster, 2006. S. 28.
66. Anna L. de. The Peoples of Finland and Early Medieval Sources: The Characterization of «Alienness»//Suomen varhaishistoria: Tornion kongressi 14.-16.6.1991/Ed. by K. Julku and M. H. Korhonen. Rovaniemi, 1992. P. 11-22
67. Gàssowski J. Dawni Sùowiane. naród czy religia?//Aetas media, aetas moderna: Studia ofiàrowane profesorowi Henrykowi Samsonowiczowi w siedemdziesiata rocznice urodzin/Red. A. Bartosiewicz et al. Warszawa, 2000. S. 257-262.
68. Русанова И. П. Истоки славянского язычества. Культовые сооружения Центральной и Восточной Европы в I тыс. до н. э.. I тыс. н. э. Чернiвцi, 2002.
69. Loma A. Procopius about the Supreme god of the Slavs (Bella VII 14.23): Two Critical Remarks//ЗРВИ. 2004. К. 41. С. 67-70.
70. Stamati I. Les petits pains en glaise -discussion sur la mentalité des habitants de l'établissement de Lazuri datant du Haut Moyen Age//Transylvanian Review. 2001. Vol. 10. Nr 2. P. 83-95.
71. Váňa Z. Archeologické doklady kultu a magie u Slovanů//Slovenská archeológia. 1988. Roč. 36. Č. 2. S. 343-352.
72. DAI 29, 32: Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De administrando imperio/Greek text ed. by Gy. Moravcsik; Engl. trans. by R. J. H. Jenkins. Washington, 1967. P. 122-153.
73. Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De administrando imperio. P. 45-47.
74. DAI 1: Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De administrando imperio. P. 49.
75. DAI 30. P. 143.
76. Pecz V. A magyarok ösi neve Konstantinos Porphyrogennetosnál//Egyetemes Philologiai Közlöny. 1896. O. 385-389.
77. Pecz V. A magyarok ösi neve Konstantinos Porphyrogennetosnál//Egyetemes Philologiai Közlöny. 1898. O. 209-221/
78. Fiók K. Sabartoiasfaloi. A mayarok régi neve Konstantinos Porphyrogennetosnál//Századok. 1896. Évf. 30. O. 607-616/
79. Fehér G. Magyarország területe a X. század közepén Konstantinos Porphyrogennetos De administrando imperioja alapján//Századok.. 1922. Évf. 56. O. 351-380.
80. Moravcsik Gy. Szövegkritikai megjegyzések Konstantinos Porphyrogennetos magyar fejezeteihez//Nyelvtudományi Közlemények. 1936. O. 285-293/
81. Kristó Gy. Konstantinos Porphyrogennetos und die Herausbildung des ungarischen Stammebundes//Acta Antiqua et Archaeologica. 1981. T. 23. O. 77-83.
82. Várady L. Revision der Ungarn-Image von Konstantinos Porphyrogenetos//BZ. 1989. Bd 82. S. 22-58.
83. Antonopoulos P. Ho autokratoros Konstantinos Z' ho Porphyrogennetos kai hoi Oungroi. Athens, 1996; Zimonyi I. Constantinus Porphyrogenitus De administrando imperio magyar fejezetének török hátterérõl//Studia varia. Tanulmányok Szádeczky-Kardoss Samu nyolcvanadik születésnapjára/Szerk. F. Makk, I. Tar, Gy. Wojtilla. Szeged, 1998. O. 159-166/
84. Kristó Gy. Konstantinos Porphyrogennetos über die Landnahme der Ungarn//Byzanz und Ostmitteleuropa, 950-1453. Beiträge zu einer table-ronde des XIX Internationalen Congress of Byzantine Studies, Copenhagen 1996/Hrsg. von G. Prinzing und M. Salamon. Wiesbaden, 1999. S. 13-22.
85. DAI 31: Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De administrando imperio. P. 151.
86. Kaldellis A. Procopius of Caesarea... P. 72.
87. Иванов С. А., Гиндин Л. А., Цымбурский В. Л. Прокопий Кесарийский//Свод древнейших письменных известий о славянах. Т. I: (I.VI вв.)/Сост. Л. А. Гиндин, С. А. Иванов, Г. Г. Литаврин. М., 1991. С. 227-228..
Контекст: ...Л. А. Гиндин, С. А. Иванов, Г. Г. Литаврин. М., 1991...

88. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars/Ed. by J. Haury; Engl. transl. by H. B. Dewing. Vol. 5. Cambridge, Mass.; London, 1924. P. 271.
89. Procopius of Caesarea Wars VII 14-26
90. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars. Vol. 5. P. 270.
91. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars II 1-7, II 23.6, III 1.6, V 14.4, VII 14.36, and VIII 5.13.
92. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars III 2.5 and V 10.6.13.
93. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VII 26.24.
94. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars IV 10.20.
95. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VIII 10.8.
96. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars II 25.4.
97. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars V 18.6.
98. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VI 1.13-19
99. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VII 14. 27-28;
100. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars. Vol. 5. P. 271, 273.
101. Procopius of Caesarea. 50 Wars VII 34.23.
102. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VIII 4.11 and VIII 3.14-15
103. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars II 21.6).
104. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars I 25.9.
105. Procopius of Caesarea. Secret History VIII 22.
106. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars IV 18.1.
107. Revanoglou E. M. Geographika kai ethnographika stoicheia. P. 208.
108. Herodotus IV 108.1.
109. Revanoglou E. M. Geographika kai ethnographika stoicheia. P. 206
110. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars III 2.4.
111. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VIII 20-28.
112. Benedicty R. Die Milieu-Theorie bei Prokop von Kaisareia//BZ. 1962. Bd 55. S. 1-10.
113. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars III 2.2-6
114. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars/Ed. by J. Haury; Engl. transl. by H. B. Dewing. Vol. 3. Cambridge, Mass.; London, 1916. P. 9, 11
115. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VII 14.24.
116. Revanoglou E. M. Geographika kai ethnographika stoicheia. P. 200-201.
117. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VI 15.2:
118. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VIII 4.9;
119. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars. Vol. 5. P. 84.
120. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VII 14.17
121. Schramm G. Venedi, Antes, Sclaveni, Sclavi: Frühe Sammelbezeichnungen für slawische Stämme und ihr geschichtlicher Hintergrund//JGO. 1995. Bd 43. S. 192.
122. Brezeanu S. Schei/Şchei. Ethnonymie et toponymie roumaines//Revue des études sud-est-européennes. 2002. Vol. 40. P. 67.
123. Филюшкин А. И. Представление о славянском этногенезе у восточноевропейских средневековых авторов//Этногенез и этнокультурные контакты славян/Отв. ред. В. В. Седов. М., 1997. С. 317-322.
124. Budak N. Prilog valorizaciji humsko-dukljanskog kulturnog podruèja u prvim fazama njegova razvitka (do 12. st.)//SHP. Split, 1986. Ser. III. Sv.16. S. 127.
125. Katičiă R. Uz početke hrvatskih početaka: Filolo.ke studije o na.em najranijem srednjovjekovlju. Split, 1994. S. 253.266; Heyduk J. Ęródůa do tzw. etnogenezy chorwatów dalmatyńskich w úwietle nowszej literatury // SA. 2003. T. 44. S. 46.
126. Ţivkoviă T. Dioclea between Rascia and Byzantium in the First Half of the 12th century//ЗРВИ. 2006. К. 43.С. 451-465
127. Ţivkoviă T. Forging Unity: The South Slavs Between East and West: 550-1150. Belgrade, 2008. P. 293-334.
128. Peričiă E. Sclavorum Regnum Grgura Barskog: Ljetopis Popa Dukljanina. Zagreb, 1991.
129. Живкови. Т. О првим поглав.има Летописа Попа Дук.анина//ИЧ. 1997. К. 44. С. 11-34.
130. Ţivkoviă T. O takozvanom saboru na Duvanjskom polju//Zbornik za istoriju Bosne i Hercegovine. 2004. Sv. 4. S. 45-65.
131. Живкови. Т. Легенда о Павлимиру Белу//ИЧ. 2004. К. 50. С. 9-32.
132. Mošin V. Ljetopis popa Dukljanina: Latinski tekst sa hrvatskim prijevodom i «Hrvatska kronika». Zagreb, 1950. S. 58.
133. Peričiă E. Sclavorum Regnum Grgura Barskog. S. 258.
134. Fine J. V. A. Croats and Slavs... S. 205-218.
135. Strumins'kyj B. Were the Antes Eastern Slavs?//HUS. 1979. Vol. 3-4. P. 792-793.
136. Werner R. Zur Herkunft der Anten: Ein ethnisches und soziales Problem der Spätantike//Kölner historische Abhandlungen. 1980. Bd 28. S. 590.
137. Wiita J. E. The Ethnika in Byzantine Military Treatises: Ph. D. dissertation, University of Minnesota. Minneapolis, 1977. P. 262.
138. Beshevliev V. Die protobulgarischen Inschriften. S. 292-293.
139. Renfrew C. The Roots of Ethnicity. Archaeology, Genetics, and the Origins of Europe. Rome, 1993.
140. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VII 14.2; English translation: Procopius of Caesarea. Wars. Vol. 5. P. 263.
141. Liebeschuetz J. H. W. G. The Lower Danube Region under Pressure: From Valens to Heraclius//The Transition to Late Antiquity on the Danube and Beyond/Ed. by A. G. Poulter. Oxford, 2007. P. 111
142. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars VII 14.6.
143. Procopius of Caesarea. Wars. Vol. 5. P. 264.
144. Oberlдnder-Tвrnoveanu E. La monnaie byzantine des VIe-VIIIe siиcles au-delа de la frontiиre du Bas-Danube. Entre politique, йconomie et diffusion culturelle//Histoire & Mesure. 2002. Vol. 17. Nr 3-4. P. 155-196
145. Степанов Ц. Етноси, съжителства, етногенезиси в ранносредновековна Европа: (Предизвикателствата на фактите и на историографските тези)//История. 2006. № 4-5. С. 35-42.
146. Matijeviг-Sokol M., Sokol V. Hrvatska i Nin u doba kneza Branimira. II. izdanje. Zagreb, 2005. S. 63-74.
147. Delonga V. Latinski epigrafiиki spomenici u ranosrednjovjekovnoj Hrvatskoj. Split, 1996. S. 252-254.
148. Stanciu I. Tonbrote' als Indiz für die Wanderung und die magisch-ritueller Glauben und Praktiken der frühen Slawen//Eastern Review. 2001. Vol. 5. P. 123-154.
149. Pecz V. A magyarok ösi neve Konstantinos Porphyrogennetosnál//Egyetemes Philologiai Közlöny. 1896. O. 800-806.
150. Váczy P. The Byzantine emperor Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus and the saga of the Hungarian conquest//Antaeus. 1990. Vol. 19-20. P. 251-256.

 

Tags: Balkans, ethnogenesis of slaves, archeology of slaves