Popov V. A. The concept of «tribe», or ethnicity and potestarity all rolled into one

Modified Date
Published Date:
Title of the article

The concept of «tribe», or ethnicity and potestarity all rolled into one

Authors Popov, Vladimir Alexandrovich — St. Petersburg State University, St. Petersburg, Russia, Doctor of science, professor, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
In the section Commentarii / Articles
Year 2015 Issue 2 Pages 13-20
Type of article RAR Index UDK   Index BBK  
Abstract The paper is devoted to the different interpretations of the term «tribe». The author concludes that modern science does not give a clear answer to the question, what is a «tribe». In mpdern literature dominates ethnic and social constructivism, extrapolating the past speculative model of the Marxist theory of primitive society. In encyclopaedic and educational literature a «tribe» is declared as primitive ethno-potestarian (ethnosocial) institute combining ethnic community and potestarian organization. The Soviet social tribes are considered as the primary form of ethnic community (as part of the well-known triad «tribe - nation - a nation»). In foreign historiography tribe is defined as the segmental nadobschinnoy political structure. Each segment in it (community, lineage) is economically independent, and leadership is personal and does not involve any formal positions. In evolutionary schemes tribe is usually placed between the primitive community and the chiefdom. The author concludes that the concept of «tribe» is characterized by the loss of the uniqueness of the terminology and the conversion to a phantom. At the same time the modern Russian ethnologist are refused to use of the concept a «tribe» and a term «ethnos» and his derivatives are used, and also «people», not having stadial attachment and not defiant associations with the primitivity. In political anthropology a «tribe» is replaced by «chiefdom» and its analogues. In other words, the concept of «tribe» has lost its former conceptuality. In political anthropology «tribe» («Potestarian tribe)» is replaced by «chiefdom» and its analogues.
Keywords tribe, ethnicity, potestarity, primitive society, chiefdom, ethnology, political anthropology
Full text version of the article. Article language Russian
  • Bromley, Yulian Vladimirovich. Ocherki teorii etnosa [Essays on the theory of ethnos]. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1983. 418 p. (in Russian).

    Fried, Morton H. The notion of tribe. Menlo Park (California): Cummings Pub. Co., 1975. 136 р.

    Girenko, Nikolay Mikhaylovich. Sotsiologiya plemeni. Stanovlenie sotsiologicheskoy teorii i osnovnye komponenty sotsial’noy dinamiki [The sociology of tribe. The genesis of sociological theory and the main components of social dynamics]. Leningrad: Nauka Publ., 1991. 302 p. (in Russian).

    Girenko, Nikolay Mikhaylovich. Tendentsii etnicheskogo razvitiya Unyamvezi v XIX v. [Tendencies of the ethnic development of Unyamwezi in the 19th century], in Etnicheskaya istoriya Afriki. Dokolonial’nyj period [Ethnic history of Africa. Pre-colonial period]. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1977. P. 70–90. (in Russian).

    Kopytov, Igor’. Protsess etnogeneza v Yugo-Zapadnom Kongo-Zaire: Vozniknovenie etnosa suku [The pro­cess of ethnogenesis in South-Western Congo-Zaire: The emergence of the Suku ethnos], in Ethnologica Africana. Pamyati D. A. Ol’derogge [Ethnologica Africana. In memoriam of D. A. Ol’derogge]. Moscow: Muravey Publ., 2002. P. 234–250. (in Russian).

    Popov, Vladimir Aleksandrovich. Algebra rodstva i vlasti. Issledovaniya po antropologii rodstva i politiches­koy antropologii [Algebra of kinship and power. Studies on the anthropology of kinship and political anthro­pology]. Moscow; St. Petersburg: Institute for African studies (RAS); Centre for the informatization of education «KIO» Publ., 2014. 400 p. (in Russian).

    Popov, Vladimir Aleksandrovich. Ashantiyskiy oman kak variant plemennoy organizatsii [Ashanti oman as a variant of tribal organization], in Afrika: Istoriya, istoriografiya [Africa: History, ethnography]. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1980. P. 4–24. (in Russian).

    Popov, Vladimir Aleksandrovich. Etnosotsial’naya istoriya akanov v XVI–XIX vekakh. Problemy genezisa i stadial’no-formatsionnogo razvitiya etnopoliticheskikh organizmov [Ethnosocial history of the Akans in the 16th–19th centuries. Problems of genesis and formational development of ethnopolitical organisms]. Moscow: «Nauka» Publ., Main Edition of Oriental Literature, 1990. 277 p. (in Russian).

    Popov, Vladimir Aleksandrovich. O korrelyatsii etnogeneticheskikh i politogeneticheskikh protsessov, ili potestarnost’ kak modus etnogeneza [On the correlation of ethnogenetic and politogenetic processes, or potestarity as a mode of ethnogenesis], in III Rossiyskiy kul’turologicheskiy kongress s mezhdunarod­nym uchastiem «Kreativnost’ v prostranstve traditsii i innovatsii». Tezisy dokladov i soobshcheniy. 27–29 oktyabrya 2010 goda [3rd Russian congress on culturology with international participation «Creativity in the sphere of tradition and innovation». Conference materials]. October 27th–29th, 2010. St. Petersburg: Eydos Publ., 2010. P. 41. (in Russian).

    Popov, Vladimir Aleksandrovich. Plemya [Tribe], in Bol’shaya Rossiyskaya entsiklopediya [Big Russian encyclopaedia]. Vol. 26. Moscow: Great Russian encyclopaedia Publ., 2014. P. 126. (in Russian).

    Popov, Vladimir Aleksandrovich. Potestarno-politicheskie faktory etnogeneza [Potestarian-political factors of ethnogenesis], in Radlovskie chteniya – 2004. Tezisy dokladov [Radlov readings – 2004. Conference materials]. St. Petersburg: Peter the Great Muzeum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), 2004. P. 53–54. (in Russian).

    Prins, Harald E. L. Tribe, in Kuper, Adam; Kuper, Jessica (eds). The Social Science Encyclopedia. London; Boston; Henley: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1985. P. 869.

    Sahlins, Marshall D. Tribesmen. Englewood Cliffs (New Jersey): Prentice-Hall, 1968. 118 р.

    Service, Elman R. Primitive social organization: An evolutionary perspective. 2nd edition. New York: Random House, 1971. 221 р.

    Service, Elman R. Origins of the state and civilization: The process of cultural evolution. New York: W. W. Norton, 1975. 361 р.

    Shnirel’man, Viktor Aleksandrovich. Protoetnos okhotnikov i sobirateley (po avstraliyskim dannym) [Proto-ethnos of hunterers and gatherers (according to Australian data)], in Bromley, Yulian Vladimirovich; Kubbel’, Lev Evgen’evich; Pershits, Abram Isaakovich (eds). Etnos v doklassovom i ranneklassovom obshchestve [Ethnos in pre-class and early class society]. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1982. P. 83–108. (in Russian).


Tags: tribe, ethnicity, potestarity, chiefdom, ethnology, political anthropology, primitive society