Lukin, Pavel Vladimirovich. Who was the «first Vsevolod»? A new interpretation of the ktetor inscription in the Saviour Church on Nereditsa Hill

For citation: Lukin, Pavel Vladimirovich. Who was the «first Vsevolod»? A new interpretation of the ktetor inscription in the Saviour Church on Nereditsa Hill, in Studia Slavica et Balcanica Petropolitana. 2022. № 2. Pp. 94-113. DOI https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu19.2022.207

Title of the article Who was the «first Vsevolod»? A new interpretation of the ktetor inscription in the Saviour Church on Nereditsa Hill
Authors

Lukin, Pavel Vladimirovich – Dr. Sc. in History, professor, Principal Researcher, Institute of Russian History, Russian Academy of Sciences, Leading Researcher, The School for Advanced Studies in the Humanities, Institute of Social Sciences, Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow, Russia, Orc ID 0000-0003-1439-0815, Researcher ID AAH-5573-2020, Scopus ID 26034050800; e-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

In the section  Fontes / Historical Sources
Year 2022 Issue 2 Pages 94-113
Type of article RAR Index UDK; BBK UDK 93/94; BBK 63.3(2)4 Index DOI https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu19.2022.207
Abstract

The article was prepared in the framework of a research grant funded by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation (grant ID 075-15-2022-326).

The author thanks all the colleagues who took part in the discussion of this text for their advice and recommendations, especially A. A. Adashinskaya, A. A. Vovin, A. A. Gippius, V. B. Krysko, A. F. Litvin, S. M. Mikheev, A. S. Preobrazhensky, E. Y. Shchegolkov. None of them is responsible for possible errors and gaps.

The article discusses a praise inscription in the Saviour Church on Nereditsa Hill, built and decorated with frescoes at the end of the 12th c. In the church there is a portrait of the ktetor, Prince Yaroslav Vladimirovich of Novgorod, with an inscription praising him, in which he is called «the God-loving prince, the second Vsevolod». The question arises: who was meant by the «first Vsevolod»? Scholars offered two candidates: the Vladimir Prince Vsevolod the Big Nest, whose protégé was Yaroslav, and the Novgorod Prince Vsevolod Mstislavich, driven out of Novgorod in 1136. Vsevolod the Big Nest, as has been shown in previous scholarship, does not fit this role, because at the time of the temple`s painting he was alive, and such exaltation did not comply with the Old Russian traditions. The main argument in favour of the candidacy of Vsevolod Mstislavich is an account of the hagiographic work, written in Pskov on the occasion of the transfer of his relics. However, it turns out to be a late and unreliable text. The author substantiates the idea that by the «first Vsevolod» may have been implied the Prince of Kiev Vsevolod Yaroslavich (1077, 1078–1093), who was the great grandfather of Yaroslav Vladimirovich. In annals there are evidences of veneration of Vsevolod Jaroslavich by his descendants, the eldest of which in the late 1190s was Yaroslav. Besides, it was Vsevolod Yaroslavich who according to some evidence was considered as a donator of the Novgorod liberties at that time. On the other hand, Yaroslav’s father Vladimir Mstislavich and Vsevolod Mstislavich were the sons of the prince of Kiev Mstislav the Great from different marriages, and belonged to the princely clans mostly warring with each other. Both for Yaroslav Vladimirovich and for Novgorodians Vsevolod Yaroslavich was a much more acceptable figure to be praised and to serve as a model for descendants. The article shows that historiography was influenced by late hagiography and modern historians’ perceptions
of the Novgorod «revolution» of 1136, of which Vsevolod Mstislavich was a victim. At the same time real dynastic beliefs of Riurikids in pre-Mongol Rus and the elite surrounding them have turned out to be almost completely forgotten.

Keywords Old Rus, Riurikids, The Saviour Church on Nereditsa Hill, prince Vsevolod Yaroslavich, prince Vsevolod Mstislavich, medieval Novgorod
Full text version of the article Article language  Russian
Bibliography

Agafonov, Ivan Sergeevich. Osada Novgoroda v 1170 godu po pis’mennym istochnikam [The siege of Novgorod in 1170 according to written sources]: PhD thesis. Moscow, 2015. 164 p. (in Russian).

Berezhkov, Nikolay Georgievich. Hronologiya russkogo letopisaniya [Chronology of the Russian chronicle]. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences Publ, 1963. 376 p. (in Russian).

Dmitriev, Benislav Sergeyevich. Knyazheskiy nekropol’ Pskovskogo Troitskogo sobora (po dannym pis’mennyh  istochnikov) [The Princely necropolis of the Pskov Trinity Cathedral (according to written sources)], in Srednevekovaya Rus’ [Medieval Russia]. Issue 9. Moscow: Indrik Publ., 2011. Pp. 153–166. (in Russian).

Dombrowski, Dariusz. Genealogiya Mstislavichey: Pervye pokoleniya (do nachala XIV v.) [Genealogy of the Mstislavichs: The first generations (before the beginning of the XIV century)]. Ed. by K. Y. Yerusalimsky and O. A. Ostapchuk. Saint Petersburg: Dmitry Bulanin Publ., 2015. (STUDIORUM SLAVICORUM ORBIS. Issue 10). 879 p. (in Russian).

Florya, Boris Nikolaevich. K izucheniyu tserkovnogo ustava Vsevoloda [To the study of the Church charter of Vsevolod], in Rossiya v Srednie veka i Novoe vremya [Russia in the Middle Ages and Modern Times]: A collection of articles for the 70th anniversary of L. V. Milov. Moscow: ROSSPEN Publ., 1999. Pp. 83–96. (in Russian).

Florya, Boris Nikolaevich. Novgorod i knyazya v XII veke [Novgorod and the Princes in the XII century], in Velikiy Novgorod i Srednevekovaya Rus’ [Veliky Novgorod and Medieval Russia]: Collection of articles: To the 80th anniversary of Academician V. L. Yanin. Moscow: Pamyatniki istoricheskoy misli Publ., 2009. Pp. 295–299. (in Russian).

Florya, Boris Nikolaevich. Predstavleniya ob otnosheniyah vlasti i obshchestva v Drevney Rusi (XII – nachalo XIII veka) [Ideas about the relations of power and society in Ancient Russia (XII – early XIII centuries)], in Vlast’ i obshchestvo v literaturnih tekstah Drevney Rusi i drugih slavyanskih stran [Power and society in literary texts of Ancient Russia and other Slavic countries]. Ed. by B. N. Florya. Moscow: Znak Publ., 2012. Pp. 9–94. (in Russian).

Gippius, Alexey Alekseevich. K istorii tserkovnogo ustava Vsevoloda [To the history of the Church Charter of Vsevolod], in Novgorod i Novgorodskaya zemlya: Istoriya i arheologiya [Novgorod and the Novgorod land: History and archeology]: Materials of the scientific conference: Novgorod, January 28–30, 2003. Veliky Novgorod, 2003. Issue. 17. Pp. 163–173. (in Russian).

Gippius, Alexey Alekseevich. Knyaz’ Yaroslav Vladimirovich i novgorodskoye obshchestvo kontsa XII veka [Prince Yaroslav Vladimirovich and the Novgorod society of the end of the XII century], in Tserkov’ Spasa na Nereditse: Ot Vizantii k Rusi: K 800-letiyu pamyatnika [Church of the Savior on Nereditsa: From Byzantium to Russia: To the 800th anniversary of the monument]. Ed. by O. E. Etingof. Moscow: Indrik Publ., 2005. Pp. 11–24. (in Russian).

Gorsky, Anton Anatolyevich. Predstavleniya o «tsare» i «tsarstve» v srednevekovoy Rusi (do serediny XVI veka) [Ideas about the «tsar» and «kingdom» in medieval Russia (until the middle of the XVI century)], in Tsar’ i tsarstvo v russkom obshchestvennom soznanii [Tsar and the kingdom in the Russian public consciousness]. Moscow: Publishing House of the Institute of Russian History of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 1999. (The worldview and self-consciousness of Russian society. Issue 2). Pp. 17–37. (in Russian).

Gorsky, Anton Anatolyevich. Titulovaniye «vseya Rusi» i russkiye knyazya XI–XIII vekov [Titling of «All Russia» and Russian princes of the XI–XIII centuries], in Gorsky, Anton Anatolyevich. «Beshchislenyya rati i velikiya trudy»: Problemy russkoy istorii XI–XV vekov [«Beschislenye rati and velikiye trudi»: Problems of Russian history of the XI–XV centuries]. St. Petersburg: Oleg Abyshko Publ., 2018. Pp. 93–95. (in Russian).

Kafenhauz, Bernhardt Borisovich. Drevniy Pskov: Ocherki po istorii feodal’noy respubliki [Ancient Pskov: Essays on the history of the feudal Republic]. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1969. 136 p. (in Russian).

Kuchkin, Vladimir Andreyevich. O prinyatii Mihailom Yaroslavichem Tverskim i vladimirskimi knyaz’yami titula «velikiy knyaz’ vseya Rusi» [On the adoption by Mikhail Yaroslavich of Tver and the Vladimir princes of the title «Grand Prince of All Russia»], in Mihail Yaroslavich Tverskoy – velikiy knyaz’ vseya Rusi [Mikhail Yaroslavich of Tver – Grand Prince of All Russia]. Tver: SFK–office Publ., 2008. Pp. 8–21. (in Russian).

Lukin, Pavel Vladimirovich. «Velikiy Novgorod [«Veliky Novgorod»], in Slověne. 2018. Vol. 7. No. 2. Pp. 383–413. (in Russian).

Lurye, Yakov Solomonovich. O proiskhozhdenii Radzivilovskoy letopisi [On the origin of the Radzivil chronicle], in Vspomogatel’niye istoricheskiye distsipliny [Auxiliary historical disciplines]. Leningrad: Nauka Publ., 1987. Issue 18. Pp. 64–82. (in Russian).

Marafioti, Nicole. The King’s Body. Burial and succession in Late Anglo-Saxon England. Toronto; Buffalo; London: University of Toronto Press, 2014. 320 p.

Mikheev, Savva Mikhailovich. Datirovannaya zapis’ o zakladke pskovskogo Troitskogo sobora Vsevolodom Mstislavichem v novgorodskoy rukopisi XII veka [Dated record of the laying of the Pskov Trinity Cathedral by Vsevolod Mstislavich in the Novgorod manuscript of the XII century], in Drevnyaya Rus’: Voprosy medievistiki [Ancient Rus: Issues of Medieval Studies]. 2022. No. 4 (90). Pp. 7–22. (in Russian).

Okhotnikova, Valentina Ilyinichna. Pskovskaya agiografiya XIV–XVII vekov: Issledovaniya i teksty [Pskov Hagiography of the XIV–XVII centuries: Studies and texts]: in 2 vols. St. Petersburg: Dmitry Bulanin Publ., 2007. Vol. 1. The Lives of Princes Vsevolod–Gabriel and Timothy–Dovmont. 276 p. (in Russian).

Okhotnikova, Valentina Ilyinichna. Tsikl proizvedeniy, posvyashchennyh knyazyu Vsevolodu-Gavriilu [A series of works dedicated to Prince Vsevolod–Gabriel], in Trudy otdela drevnerusskoy literatury [Proceedings of the Department of Ancient Russian Literature]. St. Petersburg: Dmitriy Bulanin Publ., 2006. Vol. LVII. Pp. 584–616. (in Russian).

Pivovarova, Nadezhda Valeryevna. Freski tserkvi Spasa na Nereditse v Novgorode: Ikonograficheskaya programma rospisi [Frescoes of the Church of the Savior on Nereditsa in Novgorod: Iconographic program of painting]. St. Petersburg: Ars; Dmitry Bulanin Publ., 2002. 256 p. (in Russian).

Preobrazhensky, Alexander Sergeevich. Ktitorskiye portrety srednevekovoy Rusi. XI – nachalo XVI veka [Imperial portraits of medieval Russia. XI – the beginning of the XVI century]. Moscow: Northern Pilgrim Publ., 2010. 542 p. (in Russian).

Priselkov, Mikhail Dmitrievich. Istoriya russkogo letopisaniya XI–XV vekov [The history of the Russian chronicle of the XI–XV centuries]. 2nd ed. St. Petersburg: Dmitry Bulanin Publ., 1996. (Studiorum slavicorum monumenta. T. 11). 325 p. (in Russian).

Sedova, Rimma Alekseevna. Rukopisnaya traditsiya «Zhitiya Petra» v redaktsii mitropolita Kipriana [The handwritten tradition of the «Life of Peter» edited by Metropolitan Cyprian], in Trudy otdela drevnerusskoy literatury [Proceedings of the Department of Ancient Russian Literature]. Leningrad: Institute of Russian Literature (Pushkin House) of the Russian Academy of Sciences Press, 1983. Vol. XXXVII. Pp. 256–268. (in Russian).

Shchapov, Yaroslav Nikolaevich. Knyazheskiye ustavy i tserkov’ v Drevney Rusi XI–XIV vekov [Princely charters and the Church in Ancient Russia of the XI–XIV centuries]. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1972. 340 p. (in Russian).

Sokolova, Lydia Viktorovna. K harakteristike «Slova» Daniila Zatochnika (Rekonstruktsiya i interpretatsiya pervonachal’nogo teksta) [To the characterization of the «Words» of Daniil Zatochnik (Reconstruction and interpretation of the original text)], in Trudy otdela drevnerusskoy literatury [Proceedings of the Department of Ancient Russian Literature]. Saint Petersburg: Institute of Russian Literature (Pushkin House) of the Russian Academy of Sciences Press, 1993. Vol. XLIII. Pp. 229–255. (in Russian).

Usachev, Andrey Sergeevich. Stepennaya kniga i drevnerusskaya knizhnost’ vremeni mitropolita Makariya [The Power Book and the Old Russian bookishness of the time of Metropolitan Makarii]. Moscow; St. Petersburg: Alliance-Archeo Publ., 2009. 760 p. (in Russian).

Vodoff, Vladimir. Remarques sur le valeur du terme «tsar» appliqué aux princes russes avant le milieu di XVe siècle // Vodoff, Vladimir. Princes et principautés russes (Xe – XVIIe siècles). Northampton: Variorum repr., 1989. III. P. 1–41. (in French).

Vovin, Alexey Alexandrovich. Gorodskaya kommuna srednevekovogo Pskova: XIV – nachalo XVI veka [City commune of medieval Pskov: XIV – early XVI century]. St. Petersburg: Publishing House of the European University in St. Petersburg, 2019. (Res Publica series. Issue 11). 398 p. (in Russian).

Yanin, Valentin Lavrentyevich. Novgorodskiye posadniki [Novgorod posadniki]. 2nd ed., reprint. and add. Moscow: Languages of Slavic Culture Publ., 2003. 511 p. (in Russian).

Yuryeva, Irina Sergeevna. Obshchiy tekst Kievskoy i Suzdal’skoy letopisey [The general text of the Kiev and Suzdal chronicles]. Moscow: Institute of the Russian Language Press., 2022. 207 p. (in Russian).

Zimin, Alexander Alexandrovich. Ustavnaya gramota knyazya Vsevoloda Mstislavicha [Charter of Prince Vsevolod Mstislavich], in Akademiku Borisu Dmitrievichu Grekovu ko dnyu 70-letiya [To Academician Boris Dmitrievich Grekov on the day of the 70th anniversary]: A collection of articles. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences Press, 1952. Pp. 123–131. (in Russian).

  • Hits: 196