Ermilov, Pavel Valeryevich; Chibisova, Anastasiya Aleksandrovna. The role of the Lausanne Peace Conference in the history of the Patriarchate of Constantinople as reflected in the 20th century Greek historiography: stereotypes and realities

Ermilov, Pavel Valeryevich ― PhD in History, Head of the Ecclesiastical Institutions Research Laboratory at the St. Tikhon’s Orthodox University, Moscow, Russia, pavel_ermilov@mail; OrcID 0000-0003-0881-2866;

Chibisova, Anastasiya Aleksandrovna ― graduate student, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.; OrcID 0000-0003-3698-5836

The article is written within the framework of the project «Historical and theological prerequisites of modern disagreements on the issue of primacy in the Orthodox Church» supported by PSTGU Development Foundation.

The authors analyze the attitudes of Greek scholars towards the role of the Lausanne Peace Conference held in 1922–1923 in determining the fate of the Patriarchate of Constantinople after the disintegration of the Ottoman Empire. Dealing with ecclesiastical as well as secular historiography, the authors single out a manifest tendency on the part of Greek historians towards subjectively viewing the historical data reconstructed by the authors of the present article on the basis of extant sources. The authors demonstrate that Greek scholarly literature abounds in assertions that the future fates of the Patriarchate were on the agenda of the Lausanne Conference from its very beginning, and that in the course of this Conference the terms upon which the Patriarchate could stay within Turkey and its new legal status were agreed upon; according to Greek scholars, the very fact of the Patriarchate issue emerging and being discussed during an international political conference claimed that this religious institution enjoyed a kind of international legal entity. The authors make it clear that the source of such attitudes is to be sought in the Greek government and in the stance of the leading hierarchs of the Greek Church who deemed it important to preserve at any cost the Greek ecclesiastical presence on the Turkish territory. It is precisely this goal that explains the attempt at raising the political weight of the Patriarchate of Constantinople using the authority of a major international event. In conclusion of their article, the authors cast doubts on the view that the Lausanne Peace Conference should be considered a chronological milestone in the history of the Church of Constantinople. Instead, they propose to postulate as such a milestone the emergence of the Turkish Republic and the concomitant transformation of political and religious institutions.

• Aghnides, Thanassis. The Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople in the light of the Treaty of Lausanne. New York: [n. p.], 1964. 40 p.

  Alexandris, Alexis. The Greek minority of Istanbul and Greek-Turkish relations, 1918–1974. Athens: Centre for Asia Minor Studies Publ., 1992. 194 p.

  Anastassiadis, Anastassios. Un «Vatican anglicano-orthodoxe» à Constantinople? Relations interconfessionnelles, rêves impériaux et enjeux de pouvoir en Méditerranée orientale à la fin de la Grande Guerre [An «Anglican-Orthodox Vatican» in Constantinople? Interfaith relations, Imperial Dreams and Political Stakes in the Eastern Mediterranean at the End of the Great War], in Anastassiadis, Anastassios (ed.). Voisinages fragiles: Les relations interconfessionnelles dans le Sud-Est européen et la Méditerrannée orientale 1854–1923: contraintes locales et enjeux internationaux. Athènes: École française d’Athènes Publ., 2013. Pp. 283–302 (in French).

  Balakou-Theodoroudh, Malamath. To nomiko perigramma tou Oikoumenikou Patriarcheiou sto plaisio ths diethnous koinothtas [The legal description of the Ecumenical Patriarchate within the framework of the international community]. Athens: Ekdoseis Sakkoula Publ., 2001. 400 p. (in Greek).

  Blanchet, M.-H.; Congourdeau, M.-H.; D. I. Mureşan, D. I. (eds). Le patriarcat oecuménique de Constantinople et Byzance hors frontières (1204–1586): actes de la table ronde organisée dans le cadre du 22e Congrès international des Ėtudes Byzantines, Sofia, 22–27 août 2011 [The Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople and Byzantium beyond the borders (1204–1586): proceedings of the round table organized in the context of the 22nd International Congress of Byzantine Studies, Sofia, August 22–27, 2011]. Paris: Centre d’Etudes Byzantines, Neo-Helleniques et Sud-Est Européennes Publ., 2014. 358 p. (in French).

  Chibisova, Anastasiya Aleksandrovna; Ermilov, Pavel Valer’evich. Vsepravoslavniy lider: Lozannskaya konferentsiya i rol’ Konstantinopol’skogo patriarkhata v pravoslavnom mire [Panorthodox Leader: Lausanne Conference and the Role of the Patriarchate of Constantinople in the Orthodox World], in Dialog so vremenem. 2018. Vol. 2. Pp. 186–199 (in Russian).

  Demirci, Sevtap. Strategies and struggles: British rethoric and Turkish response: the Lausanne Conference 1922–1923. Istanbul: The Isis Press, 2005. 218 p.

  Dhvanh, Lena. Ellada kai meionothtes. To systhma diethnous prostasias ths Koinonias ton Ethnon [Greece and minorities. The system of international protection of the League of Nations]. Athens: Nefelh Publ., 1995. 389 p. (in Greek).

  Diakofwtakic, Georgios. To Oikoumeniko Patriarheio meta thn Lwzannh [The Ecumenical Patriarchate after Lausanne]. Athens; Komothnh: Ekdoseis Ant. N. Sakkoula Publ., 2007. 217 p. (in Greek).

  Empeirognwmonac. H thesic tou Patriatheiou kata to Diethnec Dikaion [The status of the Patriarchate according to the International Law], in Diethneis scheseis. 1964–1965. Vol. 7. Pp. 40–54 (in Greek).

  Ermilov, Pavel Valer’evich. Proiskhozhdeniye teorii o pervenstve Konstantinopol’skogo patriarkha [The Primacy of the Patriarch of Constantinople: The Origin of the Theory], in Vestnik PSTGU. Seriya I: Bogosloviye. Filosofiya. 2014. Vol. 51. Pp. 36–53 (in Russian).

  Expulsion of the Œcumenical Patriarch (Request eventually withdrawn): Eighth (ordinary) session (June–August, 1925). Publications of the Permanent Court of International Justice. Series C: Acts and documents relating to judgments and advisory opinions given by the Court. No. 9-II. Leyden: Sijthoff Publ., 1925. 118 p.

  Fomin, Aleksandr Mikhaylovich. Voyna s prodolzheniyem: Velikobritaniya i Frantsiya v bor’be za «Osmanskoye nasledstvo», 1918–1923 [Continuing War: Great Britain and France in the struggle for the «Ottoman inheritance»]. Moscow: Dmitriy Pozharskiy University Press, 2010. 449 p. (in Russian).

  Fragkistas, Charalampos. To ametatheton tou Oikoumenikou Patriarcheiou [The non-relocatable status of the Ecumenical Patriarchate], in Diethneis scheseis. 1964–1965. Vol. 7. Pp. 34–39 (in Greek).

  Gastgeber, Christian; et al. (eds). The patriarchate of Constantinople in context and comparison: proceedings of the international conference Vienna, September 12^th–15^th 2012. Wien: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften Publ., 2017. 405 p.

  Gennadioc, mhtropoliths. Istoria kai thesis tou Oikoumenikou Patriarcheiou [History and status of the Ecumenical Patriarchate], in Diethneis scheseis. 1964–1965. Vol. 7. Pp. 5–30 (in Greek).

  Giannakakis, Basil. International Status of the Ecumenical Patriarchate, in Greek Orthodox Theological Review. 1957. Vol. 3. Pp. 26–46.

  Hirschon, Renée. Crossing the Aegean: an appraisal of the 1923 compulsory population exchange between Greece and Turkey. New York: Berghahn Books Publ., 2008. 298 p.

  Iatrou, Georgios. I thesi tou Oikomenikou Patriarcheiou sthn ekklisiastikh, thn ellinikh kai th diethnh ennomh taxh [The status of the Ecumenical Patriarchate in the ecclesiastical, Greek and international legal order]. Athens: Ekdoseis Ant. N. Sakkoula Publ., 2010. 677 p.

  Karykopoulou, Chrysoula. To diethnhc kathestws tou Oikoumenikou Patriarheiou [The international status of the Ecumenical Patriarchate]. Athens: Ekdoseis Grhgorh Publ., 1979. 125 p. (in Greek).

  Kitromilides, Paschalis. Religion and politics in the Orthodox World: Ecumenical Patriarchate and the challenges of modernity. Abingdon, Oxon; New York: Routledge Publ., 2019. 130 p.

  Konidarhc, Iwannhs M. Idiaitera ekklhsiastika kathestwta sthn ellhnikh epikrateia [Particular ecclesiastical regimes in the Greek territory]. Athens; Thessaloniki: Sakkoulas Publ., 2012. 306 p. (in Greek).

  Konstantinides, Chrysostomos. The Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Ecumenical Patriarchs from the Treaty of Lausanne (1923) to the Present, in Greek Orthodox Theological Review. 2000. Vol. 45. Pp. 5–22.

  Lausanne Conference on Near Eastern Affairs (1922–1923). Records of Proceedings and Draft Terms of Peace. London: His Majesty’s Stationery Office Publ., 1923. 861 p.

  Mamalos, Georgios-Spyridon. To Patriarheio Kwnstantinoupolews kata thn periodo 1918–1972: Diethnhs politikh kai oikoumenikos prosanatolismos [The Patriarchate of Constantinople in 1918–1972: International Politics and Ecumenical Orientation]. Athens; Komothnh: Ekdoseis Ant. N. Sakkoula Publ., 2011. 482 p. (in Greek).

  Mango, Andrew. From the Sultan to Atatürk: Turkey. London: Haus Histories Publ., 2009. 226 p.

  Papadopoullos, Theodore. Orthodox Church and civil authority, in Journal of Contemporary History. 1967. Vol. 2 (4). Pp. 201–209.

  Psomiades, Harry. Soviet Russia and the Orthodox Church in the Middle East, in Middle East Journal. 1957. Vol. 11 (4). Pp. 371–381.

  Psomiades, Harry. The Eastern question: The last phase: A study in Greek-Turkish diplomacy. Θεσσαλονίκη: Institute for Balkan Studies Press, 1968. 145 p.

  Papadakhs, Loukas D. O dekatos tritos Apostolos: praxeis Meletiou Metaxakh [The Thirteenth Apostle: Life of Meletius Metaxakis]. Heraklion: [n. p.], 2014. 850 p. (in Greek).

  Rafth, Eleutheria. O Oikoumenikos Thronos ws thesmos dikaiou (to nomikon kathestwc tou Oikoumenikou Patriarheiou) [The Ecumenical Throne as a legal institution (the legal status of the Ecumenical Patriarchate)], in Klhronomia. 1984. Vol. 16. Pp. 5–129 (in Greek).

  Runciman, Steven. The Great Church in captivity: study of the Patriarchate of Constantinople from the eve of the Turkish conquest to the Greek War of Independence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988. 454 p.

  Rustem Bey, Ahmed. The Future of the Œcumenical Patriarchate, in Foreign Affairs. 1925. Vol. 3 (4). Pp. 604–610.

  Shkarovskiy, Mikhail Vitalyevich. Konstantinopol’skiy Patriarkhat i Russkaya Pravoslavnaya Tserkov’ v pervoy polovine XX veka [Patriarchate of Constantinople and Russian Orthodox Church in the First Half of the 20^th century]. Moscow: Indrik Publ., 2014. 232 p. (in Russian).

  Stauridhc, Basileios. Oi Oikoumenikoi Patriarhai 1860 — Shmeron [Ecumenical Patriarchs 1860 — Today]. Thessaloniki: Etaireia Makedonikwn Spoudwn Publ., 1977. Vol. 1. 694 p. (in Greek).

  Ténékidès, Ciriaque Georges. L’expulsion du Patriarche œcuménique et le conflit gréco-turc [The expulsion of the Ecumenical Patriarch and the Greek-Turkish conflict], in Revue Générale de droit international public. 1925. Vol. 32. Pp. 102–111 (in French).

  Ürer, Levent. Azınlıklar ve Lozan tartışmaları [Minorities and Lausanne discussions]. İstanbul: Derin Yayınları Publ., 2003. 332 p. (in Turkish).

  Yfantidhc, Euaggelos. Oikoumeniko Patriarheio kai Politikes Dynameis: Apo th Syndiaskepsh thc Lwzannhs ews thn eklogh tou Patriarhh Basileiou III [Ecumenical Patriarchate and Political Forces: From the Lausanne Conference to the election of Patriarch Basil III]. Kavala: Patriarchiko Idryma Paterikon Meleton Publ., 2014. 558 p. (in Greek).