Dzino D. Becoming Slav, becoming Croat: new directions in research of identities in late antique and early medieval Illyricum

Modified Date
Published Date:
Title of the article  Becoming Slav, becoming Croat: new directions in research of identities in late antique and early medieval Illyricum
Authors  Dzino D. -  University of Adelaide (Australia)
In the section  Commentarii / Articles
Year 2008 Issue  2 Pages  37-58
Type of article RAR Index UDK  94(497.5) ?+903(-161.1)+ 94(495).01 Index BBK  
Abstract  The paper deals with the processes of identity constructions in late antique and early medieval Illyricum. The most significant conclusion is that there were two separate processes. The first is the process of acculturation, the indigenous population "becoming Slavs", following the "Slav migrations" of the 6th and 7th century. The second process occurs in the 9th century, after the disintegration of the Anvar qaganate, the foundation of the Byzantine thema Dalmatia and the establishment of the Carolingian empire. The changed political cicumstances initiated a formation of more complex political institutions and new identities, such asthe Croats, developed in post-Roman Illyricum.
Keywords  ethnogenesis of slaves, Balkans, Croatia, archeology of slaves, avarian kaganate
Full text version of the article Article language  
Bibliography

1. Curta F. Southeastern Europe in the Middle Ages 500-1250. Cambridge, 2006.
2. Todorova M. Imagining Balkans. Oxford,1997.
3. Rendić-Miočević D. Retracing the past to the cradle of Croatian History//EEQ. 2002. Vol. 36. Nr 1. P. 2.
4. Curta F. The Making of the Slavs: History and Archaeology of the Lower Danube Region, c. 500-700. Cambridge, 2001. P. 6-35.
5. Barth F. Introduction//Ethnic Groups and Boundaries/Ed. by F. Barth. Bergen, 1969. P. 9-38
6. Барт Ф. Введение//Этнические группы и социальные границы. Социальная организация культурных различий/Под ред. Ф. Барта; Пер. И. Пильщикова. М., 2006. С. 9-48.
7. Cohen A. Custom and politics in urban Africa: A study of Hausa migrants in Yoruba towns. London, 1969.
8. The anthropology of ethnicity: Beyond 'Ethnic groups and boundaries'/Ed. by H. Vermeulen, C. Govers. Amsterdam; Hague, 1994.
9. Jenkins R. Rethinking ethnicity: Identity, categorization and power//ERS. 1993. Vol. 17. Nr 2. P. 197-223.
10. Anderson B. Imagined communities: Reflections on the origins and spread of nationalism. London, 1983.
11. Андерсон Б. Воображаемые сообщества: Размышления об истоках и распространении национализма/Пер. В. Г. Николаева. М., 2001.
12. Eller J., Coughlin R. The poverty of primordialism: The demystification of ethnic attachments//ERS. 1993. Vol. 6. Nr 2. P. 183-202.
13. Said E. Orientalism. London, 1978.
14. Саид Э. Ориентализм: Западные концепции Востока/Пер. А. В. Говорунова. СПб., 2006.
15. Shennan S. J. Introduction: Archaeological approaches to Cultural Identity//Archaeological Approaches to Cultural Identity/Ed. by S. J. Shennan. New York, 1989. P. 1-32.
16. Jones S. The Archaeology of Ethnicity: Constructing identities in the past and present. London, 1997.
17. Brather S. Etnische Interpretationen in der früchgeschichtlicher Archäologie: Geschichte, Grundlagen und Alternativen. Berlin; New York, 2004.
18. Curta F. Some remarks on ethnicity in medieval archaeology//EME. 2007. Vol. 15. № 2. P. 159-185
19. Bourdieau P. Outline of a Theory of Practice. Cambridge, 1977.
20. Bourdieau P. The Logic of Practice. Cambridge, 1990.
21. Nationalism and archaeology in Europe/Ed. by M. Díaz-Andreu, T. Champion. London, 1996.
22. Cultural Identity and Archaeology: The construction of European communities/Ed. by P. Graves-Brown, S. Jones, S. Gamble. London; New York, 1996.
23. Anthony D. Migration in archaeology: the baby and the bathwater//American Anthropologist. 1990. Vol. 92. Nr 4. P. 895-914.
24. Härke H. Archeologists and Migrations: A problem of attitude [and Comments and Reply]//Current Anthropology. 1998. Vol. 39. Nr 1. P. 19-45.
25. Effros B. Merovingian Mortuary Archaeology and the Making of Early Middle Ages. Berkely, 2003.
26. Halsall G. Early Medieval Cemeteries: An Introduction to Burial Archeology in the Post-Roman West. Skelmorlie, 1995.
27. Härke H. «Warrior Graves»? The Background of the Anglo-Saxon Weapon Burial Rite//Past and Present. 1990. Vol. 126. P. 22-43.
28. Hartog F. Le miroir d'Herodote: Essai sur la representation de l'autre. Paris, 1980.
29. Wells P. The Barbarians Speak: How the conquered peoples shaped Roman Europe. Princeton, 1999.
30. Ferris I. Enemies of Rome: Barbarians through Roman Eyes. Stroud, 2000.
31. Geary P. The Myth of Nations: the Medieval origins of Europe. Princeton, 2002. P. 41-62.
32. Wolfram H. Einleitung oder Überlegungen zur Origo Gentis//Typen der Ethnogenese unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Bayern. T. I/Hrsg. von H. Wolfram und W. Pohl. Wien, 1990. S. 19-33.
33. Goffart W. The Narrators of Barbarian History. Princeton, 1988.
34. Curta F. The Making of the Slavs. P. 36-119.
35. Pohl W. Die Völkerwanderung: Eroberung und Integration. Stuttgart; Berlin; Köln, 2002
36. Curta F. The Making of the Slavs..
37. Goffart W. Barbarian tides: The Migration Age and the Later Roman Empire. Philadelphia, 2006.
38. Amory P. People and identity in Ostrogothic Italy, 489-554. Cambridge; New York, 1997.
39. Strategies of distinction: the construction of ethnic communities, 300-800/Hrsg. von W. Pohl und H. Reimitz. New York; Leiden, 1998.
40. On Barbarian Identity: Critical Approaches to Identity in the Early Middle Ages/Ed. by A. Gillett. Turnhout, 2002.
41. Wolfram H. Das Reich und die Germanen: Zwischen Antike und Mittelalter, Das Reich und die Deutschen. Berlin, 1990.
42. Pohl W. Aux origins d'une Europe ethnique. Transformations d'identités entre Antiquité et Moyen Âge // Annales: Histoire, sciences socials. 2005. T. 60. P. 183-208.
43. Goffart W. Rome's Fall and After. London; Ronceverte, 1989.
44. Bowlus C. R. Ethnogenesis Models and the Age of Migrations: A Critique//Austrian History Yearbook. 1995. Vol. 26. P. 147-164.
45. Gillett A. Ethnogenesis: A Contested Model of Early Medieval Europe//History Compass. 2006. Vol. 4. P. 241-260.
46. Šimunović P. The evidence provided by proper names in the early centuries//Croatia in the Early Middle Ages: A Cultural Survey (Croatia and Europe 1). London; Zagreb, 1999. P. 401-404.
47. Piteša A. The Slavs and the Early Croatian state//Dalmatia: Research in the Roman Province 1970-2001. Papers in honour of J. J. Wilkes (British Archaeological Reports 1576). Oxford, 2006. P. 195-197
48. Miletić N. Ranoslovenske nekropole u Bosni i Hercegovini. Komparativna razmatranja // GZM BiH. Nova serija. 1989. T. 44. S. 175-200.
49. Sokol V. The archaeological heritage of the early Croats//Croatia in the Early Middle Ages: A Cultural Survey (Croatia and Europe 1). London; Zagreb, 1999. P.117-119.
50. Evans H. The Early Medieval Archaeology of Croatia AD 600-900: (British Archaeological Reports 539). Oxford, 1989. Fig. 4.4
51. Mrkobrad D. Bibliografija Seobe Naroda u Jugoslaviji. Beograd, 1984.
52. Curta F. The Making of the Slavs… P. 247-310.
53. Brather S. The Beginnings of Slavic Settlement East of the River Elbe//Antiquity. 2004. Vol. 78. P. 314-329.
54. Curta F. Frontier Ethnogenesis in Late Antiquity: The Danube, the Tervingi, and the Slavs//Borders, Barriers and Ethnogenesis/Ed. by F. Curta. Turnhout, 2005. P. 173-204.
Контекст: ...Ф. Курта недавно подчеркнул политизацию культурного габитуса как основу конструирования этничности в раннем Средневековье: Curta F. 1) Frontier Ethnogenesis in Late Antiquity: The Danube, the Tervingi, and the Slavs // Borders, Barriers and Ethnogenesis / Ed. by F. Curta. Turnhout, 2005...

55. Curta F. Some Remarks on Ethnicity in Medieval Archaeology//EME. 2007. Vol. 15. Nr 2. P. 159-185.
56. Suić M. Antički grad na istočnom Jadranu. Zagreb, 1976. S. 227-262.
57. Suić M. Continuity of urban civilization in the Croatian lands//Croatia in the Early Middle Ages: A Cultural Survey (Croatia and Europe 1). London; Zagreb, 1999. P. 103-111.
58. Čače S. Civitates Dalmatiae u «Kozmografiji» Anonima Ravenjanina. Zadar, 1995.
59. Suić M. Antički grad. S. 235-251.
60. Mužić I. Hrvatska povijest devetoga stoljeća. II izdanje. Split, 2007. S. 111-116.
61. Vinski Z. Rani srednji vijek u Jugoslaviji od 400. do 800. godine//Vjesnik Arheolo.kog muzeja u Zagrebu. Serija III. 1971. Vol. 5. S. 43-73.
62. Evans H. The Early Medieval Archaeology. Fig. 4.4.
63. Miložević A. Porijeklo i datiranje keramièkih posuda u grobovima ranog srednjeg vijeka u Dalmaciji//Diadora. 1990. Nr 12. S. 327-369.
64. Miložević A. Komanski elementi i pitanje kasnoantičkog kontinuiteta u materijalnoj kulturi ranosrednjovjekovne Dalmacije//Etnogeneza Hrvata/Ur. N. Budak. Zagreb, 1995. S. 97-104;
65. Vinski Z. Autohtoni kulturni elementi u doba doseljenja Slavena na Balkan//Predslavenski etnički elementi na Balkanu u etnogenezi južnih Slovena: (Posebna izdanja ANU BiH. Knj. XII: Centar za balkanolo.ka istra.ivanja. Knj. 4). Sarajevo, 1969. S. 171-200.
66. Mužić I. Hrvatska povijest... S. 87-120.
67. Marković M. Antička naselja i grčko-rimska zemljopisna imena na tlu današnje Hrvatske. Zagreb, 2004. S. 207-216.
68. Klaić N. Povijest Hrvata u srednjem vijeku. Zagreb, 1990. S. 18.24;.vab M. Dana.nje stanje historiografije o pojavi Hrvata na istočnoj obali Jadrana//Etnogeneza Hrvata/Ur. N. Budak. Zagreb, 1995. S. 54-60.
69. Katičić R. The Origins of the Croats//Croatia in the Early Middle Ages: A Cultural Survey (Croatia and Europe 1). London; Zagreb, 1999. P. 155-166.
70. Fine J. Croats and Slavs; theories about the historical circumstances of the Croats. appearance in the Balkans // BF. 2000. Bd 26. S. 205-218.
71. Ward-Perkins B. Why did the Anglo-Saxons not become more British?//English Historical Review. 2000. Vol. 115. Nr 462. P. 526.
72. Dzino D. Delmati, vino i formiranje etničkog identiteta u predrimskom Iliriku//VAPD. 2006. Sv. 99. S. 71-80.
73. Šašel-Kos M. Appian and Illiricum. (Situla 43). Ljubljana, 2005. S. 219-244.
74. Dzino D. «Deconstructing "Illyrians"»: Zeitgeist, changing perceptions and the identity of peoples from ancient Illyricum//Croatian Studies Review. Sydney, 2007. Vol. 5-6.
75. Mуcsy A. Pannonia and Upper Moesia. London, 1974. P. 250-263.
76. Wilkes J. Illyrians. Oxford; Cambridge, 1992. P. 254-259..
77. Rendić-Miočević D. Iliri i Antički svijet: Ilirolo.ke studije. Split, 1989.
78. Rendić-Miočević D., Pedišić I. Noveaux témoignages épigraphiques du culte du Sylvain á Rider//Illyrica Antiqua: Ob honorem Duje Rendić-Miočević/Ur. M.egvić, I. Mirnik. Zagreb, 2005. S. 415-418.
79. Bojanovski I. Bosna i Hercegovina u antičko doba. (Djela ANU BiH. Knj. LXVI. Centar za balkanološka istraživanja. Knj. 6). Sarajevo, 1988. S. 72-74.
80. Woolf G. Becoming Roman: The origins of provincial civilization in Gaul. Cambridge, 1998.
81. Webster J. Creolizing the Roman provinces//American Journal of Archaeology. 2001. Vol. 105/2. P. 209-225.
82. Hingley R. Globalizing Roman culture: Unity, diversity and empire. London; New York, 2005.
83. Alföldy G. Die «illyrischen» provinzen Roms: von der Vierfalt zu der Einheit//Dall'Adriatico al Danubio: L'Illirico nell'età graeca e romana: I convegni della fondazione Niccolò Canussio 3. Pisa, 2004. P. 207-220.
84. Jarak M. Questions concerning christianization of autochtonous romanized population of Dalmatia//Illyrica Antiqua: Ob honorem Duje Rendić-Miočević. S. 305-314.
85. Margetić L. Iz starije hrvatske povijesti//Radovi zavoda povijesnih znanosti HAZU. Zadar, 2001. Knj. 43. S. 1-11.
86. Andrić S. Savsko-dravsko međurječje od kasne antike do ranog srednjeg vijeka//Scrinia Slavonica. 2002. Vol. 2. S. 129-163.
87. Curta F. Southeastern Europe… P. 39-69.
88. Curta F. Frontier Ethnogenesis… P. 173-204.
89. Elton H. Defining Romans, Barbarians and Roman Frontier//Shifting Frontiers in Late Antiquity/Ed. by R. Mathisen, H. Sivan. Aldershot, 1996. P. 126-135.
90. Trifunović S. Slovenska naselja V-VII veka u Bačkoj i Banatu//Труды VI Международного конгресса славянской археологии. Т. I: Проблемы славянской археологии. М., 1997. С. 173-185.
91. Curta F. Invasion or inflation? Sixth-to seventh-century Byzantine coin hoards in Eastern and Southeastern Europe//Annali dell'Istituto Italiano di Numismatica. 1996. Nr 43. P. 65-224.
92. Fitzpatrick A. P. «Celtic» Iron Age Europe: the theoretical basis//Cultural Identity and Archaeology: The construction of European communities/Ed. by P. Graves-Brown, S. Jones, S. Gamble. London; New York, 1996. P. 238-255.
93. Wells P. The Barbarians Speak... P. 99.
94. Curta F. The Making of the Slavs. P. 36-73
95. Cameron A. Procopius. London, 1985. P. 218-219.
Контекст: ...Об этнографических стереотипах Прокопия см.: Cameron A. Procopius. London, 1985...

96. Lončar M. Porfirogenetova seoba Hrvata pred sudom novije literature//Diadora. 1992. Sv. 14. S. 375-448.
97. Katičić R. The Origins of the Croats. P. 151-155.
98. Curta F. Southeastern Europe… P. 137-139.
99. Katičić R. Die Anfänge des kroatischen Staates//Die Bayern und ihre Nachbarn. T. I/Hrsg. von H. Wolfram und A. Schwarz. Wien, 1985. S. 299-312.
100. Evans H. The Early Medieval Archaeology. P. 64-85.
101. ВИИНJ. Т. II. С. 37-46.
102. Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De administrando imperio. Vol. II: Commentary. London, 1962. P. 1-8.
103. Toynbee A. Constantine Porphyrogenitus and His World. London, 1973. P. 581-582.
104. Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De administrando imperio/Greek text ed. by Gy. Moravcsik; Engl. transl. by R. J. H. Jenkins. Washington, 1967.
105. Constantinus Porphyrogenitus. De ceremoniis aulae byzantinae libri II/E rec. Io. Iac. Reiskii. Bonnae, 1829. P. 5.
106. Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De administrando imperio…
107. Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De administrando imperio…
108. Obolensky D. Byzantium and the Slavs: Collected Essays. New York, 1994. P. 13.
109. Hunger H. On the imitation (mimesis) of Antiquity in Byzantine Literature//DOP. 1969/70. Vol. 23. Nr 4. P. 15-38.
110. Mango C. Byzantine Literature as a Distorting Mirror//Byzantium and the Classical Tradition/Ed. M. Mullett, R. Scott.Birmingham, 1981. P. 3-18.
111. Marincola J. M. Authority and Tradition in Ancient Historiography. Cambridge, 1997.
112. Bury J. B. The Treatise De Administrando Imperio//BZ. 1906. Bd 15. Nr 3-4. S. 530.
113. Toynbee A. Constantine Porphyrogenitus... P. 599-600.
114. Obolensky D. The Byzantine Commonwealth. New York, 1971. P. 353-359.
115. Obolensky D. Byzantium and the Slavs. P. 1-22.
116. Haldon J. F. Ideology and social change in the seventh century: Military discontent as a barometer//Klio. 1986. Vol. 68. P. 161-173.
117. Haldon J. F. Byzantium in the Seventh Century. Cambridge, 1990. P. 348-371.
118. Woolf G. Becoming Roman. P. 54-60.
119. Hingley R. Globalizing Roman culture... P. 62-71.
120. Pohl W. Telling the Difference: Signs of Ethnic Identity//Strategies of Distinction: The Construction of Ethnic Communities, 300-800/Ed. by W. Pohl, H. Reimitz. New York; Leiden, 1998. P. 17-70.
121. Bojanovski I. Bosna i Hercegovina u antičko doba. (Djela ANU BiH. Knj. LXVI. Centar za balkanološka istraživanja. Knj. 6). Sarajevo, 1988. S. 345-354.

 

Tags: Croatia, Balkans, ethnogenesis of slaves, archeology of slaves, avarian kaganate