Homza, Martin. A few words about the identity of the Slavs, yesterday, today and tomorrow

Modified Date
Published Date:

Tags: Great Moravia, Cyril and Methodius, Slavs, Sts Cyril and Methodius, Commentarii / Articles, HOMZA M.

Title of the article A few words about the identity of the Slavs, yesterday, today and tomorrow
Authors Homza, Martin — Doctor in History, Professor, Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovakia. This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.; Scopus ID 56043614800
In the section Commentarii / Articles
Year 2018 Issue 1 Pages 3-41
Type of article RAR Index UDK; BBK УДК 94(47+57)(=16); ББК  Т3(49=Сл)4 ndex DOI https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu19.2018.101
Abstract This paper brings together the considerations that for many years the author has gathered on the origin, identity and successful expansion of the Slavs throughout the world. The author notes that although the issue of post-Roman social self-identification has been discussed for several decades not only in Europe but also worldwide, a deeper understanding of the apparition and expansion of the Slavic identity has not yet been achieved. In the author’s opinion, the success of the Slavic identity was the result of the quality and attractiveness of the Slavic cultural memory, whose evolution shows three basic stages following the necessary starting point, i.e. the revolutionary decision taken by the military community at the Low and Middle Danube to adopt the name Slav. The first phase is the formation of their cultural memory, which just like that of other barbarian military communities (gentes) in the aftermath of the fall of the Roman Empire, was built on the literary (oral) transmission of the narrative that told the glorious deeds of the community and its elite (ruler, dynasty, retinue). The second and third stages of the development of the Slavic identity constitute the historically relatively short period of the Great Moravia, beginning and ending in the 9th century. On a political level, the increased attractiveness of the self-identification concept of the Slavic elites resulted in the vastest territorial expansion of the land of the Danubian Slavs during the reign of Svatopluk I and the formal constitution of the Slavic Kingdom, which was recognised by both, Rome and the Empire. On a cultural level, however, the success of the Moymirid dynasty was outperformed by the missionary work of St. Constantine the Philosopher and his brother St Methodius, who created the Slavic alphabet and the Slavonic liturgical language, translated the Sacred Scriptures, wrote some original literature works, etc. The author considers the Christian concept of self-identification, built on the identical wording of the word Logos, i.e. Slovo (Word) and Slovan (Slav) — which was developed by St. Constantine the Philosopher — to have become the nomen est omen of the past, the present and the future of the Slavs.
Keywords Slavs, Slavic identity, Great Moravia, Sts Cyril and Methodius
Full text version of the article. Article language English
References
  • Abrams, Lesley. Diaspora and Identity in the Viking Age, in Early Medieval Europe. 2012. Vol. 20. P. 17–38.

    Assman, Jan. Collective Memory and Cultural Identity, in Cultural History / Cultural Studies. 1995. Vol. 65. P. 125–133.

    Avenarius, Alexander. K problematike avarskoslovanského vzťahu na dolnom Dunaji v 6.–7. stor. [On the problem of the Avar-Slavic relations in the Lower Danube region], in Slovanské štúdie. 1971. Vol. 11. P. 223–244 (in Slovak).

    Avenarius, Alexander. Die Awaren in Europa [The Avars in Europe]. Transl. by Nováková, Uršula. Amsterdam; Bratislava, 1974. 283 p. (in Slovak).

    Avenarius, Alexander. Začiatky Slovanov na strednom Dunaji: autochtonistická teória vo svetle súčasného bádania [Origins of the Slavs in the Middle Danube region: The autochtonist theory in the light of contemporary research], in Historický časopis. 1992. Vol. 40. No. 1. P. 1–15 (in Slovak).

    Barford, Paul. The Early Slavs: Culture and Society in Early Medieval Eastern Europe. London: British Museum Press, 2001. 416 p.

    Brather, Sebastian. Ethnische Interpretationen in der frühgeschichtlichen Archäologie: Geschichte, Grundlagen und Alternativen [Ethnic Interpretations in Early Medieval Archaeology: History, Basis, and Alternatives]. Berlin; New York, Walther de Gruyter Publ., 2004. 807 p.

    Brather, Sebastian. The Archaeology of the Northwestern Slavs (Seventh To Ninth Centuries), in East Central Europe. 2004. Vol. 31. No. 1. P. 78–81.

    Brown, Elizabeth A. R. Myths Chasing Myth: The Legend of the Trojan Origin of the French and its Dismantling, in Nagy, Balász; Sebők, Marcell (eds).The Man of Many Devices, who Wandered full Many Ways... : Festschrift in Honor of János M. Bak.  Budapest, CEU Press, 1999. P. 613–633.

    Curta, Florin. The making of the Slavs. History and archaeology of the Lower Danube Region, c. 500–700. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001. 436 p.

    Curta, Florin. From Kossina to Bromley — Ethnogenesis in Slavic Archeology, in Gillett, Andrew (ed.). Barbarian Identity: Critical Approaches to Ethnicity in the Early Middle Ages. Turnhout: Brepols, 2002. P. 201–218.

    Curta, Florin. The Slavic lingua franca: Linguistic Notes of an Archeologist Turned Historian, in East Central Europe. 2004, Vol. 31. No. 1. P. 125–148.

    Curta, Florin. The Making of the Slavs: Slavic Ethnogenesis Revisited, in Repič, Jaka; Bartulović, Alenka; Sajovec Altshul, Katarina (eds.). MESS and RAMSES II. Mediterranean Ethnological Summer School. Vol. 7. Ljubljana, Znanstvena založba Filozofske fakultete Publ., 2008. P. 277–307.

    Dostálová, Růžena. Byzantská vzdělanost [Byzantine Education]. Praha, Vyšehrad Publ., 1990. 416 p.

    Dvornik, Francis. The Slavs Their Early History and Civilization. Boston, American Academy of Arts and Sciences Publ., 1956. 394 p.

    Dzino, Danijel. Becoming Slav, becoming Croat: identity transformations in post-Roman and early medieval Dalmatia. Leiden: Brill, 2010. 272 p.

    Ďurina, Ľubomír. Malá knižná reminiscencia [Small book reminiscence], in Proglas. 1999. Vol. 10. No. 2. P. 11–14 (in Slovak).

    Florya, Boris Nikolaevich. Skazanie o prelozhenii knig na slovenskiy yazyk: Istochniki, vremya i mesto napisaniya [The Tale of the translation of books into the Slavic language: Sources, Date and Place of Composition], in Byzantinoslavica. 1985. Vol. 46. No. 1. P. 121–130 (in Russian).

    Fried, Johannes. Otton III i Bolesław Chrobry [Otto III and Boleslas the Brave]. Transl. by Kaźmierczak, Elżbieta; Leder, Witold. Warszawa, Wiedza Powszechna Publ., 2000. 270 p.

    Geary, Patrick. Ethnic Identity as a Situational Construct in the Early Middle Ages, in Mitteilungen der anthropologischen Gesellschaft. 1983. Vol. 113. P. 15–26.

    Geary, Patrick. The Crisis of European Identity Barbarian Ethnicity and Identityin Noble, Thomas F. X. (ed.) From Roman Provinces to Medieval Kingdoms. London; New York: Routledge, 2006. P. 27–34.

    Geary, Patrick J. Barbarians and ethnicity, in Bowersock, Glen Warren; Brown, Peter; Grabar, Oleg (eds.). Interpreting late antiquity: Essays on the postclassical world. London, Belknap Press, 2001. P. 107–129.

    Graus, František. Raně středověké družiny a jejich význam při vzniku států ve střední Evropě [Early medieval retinues of warriors and its meaning in state building in Central Europe], in Československý časopis historický. 1965. Vol. 13. No. 1. P. 1–18 (in Czech).

    Homza, Martin. Niekoľko téz k počiatkom slovenského etnika [Several theses on the origins of the Slovak nation], in Studia Academica Slovaca. 2002. Roč. 31. P. 285–295 (in Slovak).

    Homza, Martin. Uhorsko-poľská kronika: nedocenený prameň k dejinám strednej Európy [Hungarian-Polish chronicle: An unappreciated source to the history of Central  Europe]. Bratislava, Post Scriptum Publ., 2009. 223 p. (in Slovak).

    Homza, Martin. StrednáEurópa I. Na začiatku stredoveku [Central Europe I. At the beginning of the Middle Ages]. Bratislava, Comenius University Publ., 2014. 313 p. (in Slovak).

    Homza, Martin. La Grande Moravia tra Oriente e Occidente [Great Moravia Between East and West], in Hrabovec, Emilia; Piatti, Pierantonio; Tolomeo, Rita (eds). I Santi Cirillo e Metodio e la loro eredità religiosa e culturale ponte tra Oriente e Occidente. Raccolta di studi in occasione del 1150° anniversario della missione dei santi Cirillo e Metodio nella Grande Moravia (863-2013) [Saints Cyril and Methodius and their Religious Heritage and Cultural Bridge between East and West. Collection of studies on the 1150th anniversary of the mission of Saints Cyril and Methodius in the Great Moravia (863–2013)]. Città del Vaticano: Libreria Editrice Vaticana Publ., 2015. P. 23–33 (in Italian).

    Homza, Martin. Back to the Subject of the Royal Title of Svätopluk I , or Reply to Ján Steinhübel and Other Present and Past AntidicoSvätoplukians, in Slovak Studies. 2016. No. 1–2. P. 160–186.

    Homza, Martin. Niekoľko slov k dialógu svätého Konštantína Filozofa s Agarénmi (Saracénmi)a otázke chápania vojny v ňom, in Letková, Alexandra; Lysý, Miroslav; Považan, Michal (eds.). Vojna a vojenstvo v práve: Zborník z medzinárodnej vedeckej konferencie, konanej dňa 5. 11.2015 v Bratislave.  Bratislava, Univerzita Komenského Publ.,2016. P. 27–44.

    Homza, Martin. 14. marec roku 1074 a jeho dôsledky na vývoj Nitrianskeho kniežatstva, in Letz, Róbert (ed.). Slovenské územie. Martin, Matica slovenská Publ., 2017. P. 45–-65.

    Homza, Martin. Hranice Nitrianskeho vojvodstva (kniežatstva) v poľských stredovekých kronikách [Borders of the Nitra Duchy (Principality) in Medieval Polish Chronicles], in Marsina, Richard (ed.). Nitrav slovenských dejinách. Martin, Matica Slovenská Publ., 2002. P. 65–78 (in Slovak).

    Homza,Martin; etal. Svätoplukv europskom pisomnictve. Študie z dejin svatoplukovskej legendy[Svatopluk in European literature. Studies on the history of the Svatopluk legend]. Bratislava, Post Scriptum Publ.,2013. 749 p. (in Slovak).

  • Homza, Martin; Rácová, Naďa. K vývinu slovenskej myšlienky do polovice 18. storočia [On the Development of the Slovak Idea before the Middle of the 18th Century]. Bratislava, Stimul Publ., 2010. 275 p. (in Slovak).

    Horák Antonín. O Slovanech úlně jinak: Co nebylo o Slovanech dosud známo [On the Slavs in Totally Other Way: What Was not Known About the Slavs to This Day]. Vizovice: LÍPA Publ., 1991. 318 p. (in Czech).

    Hromník, Cyril A. Sloveni a Slovensko [Slovaks and Slovakia]. Martin, Matica slovenská, 2015. 928 p. (in Slovak).

    Hurbanič, Martin. Posledná vojna antiky: Avarský útok na Konštantínopol roku 626 v historických súvislostiach [Last War of Antiquity: The Avar Siege of Constantinople of 626 in Historical Circumstances]. Prešov, Michal Vlaško Publ.,  2009. 377 p. (in Slovak.)

    Jones, Siân. The Archaeology of Ethnicity: Constructing identities in the past and present. London, Routledge Publ., 1997. 200 p.

    Kohut, Zenon E. From Japheth to Moscow: Narrating Biblical and Ethnic Origins of the Slavs in Polish, Ukrainian, and Russian Historiography (Sixteenth-Eighteenth Centuries), in Journal of Ukrainian Studies. 2008–2009. Vol. 33–34. P. 27–292.

    Kradin, Nikolay Nikolaevich. Kochevniki Yevrazii [Nomads of Eurasia]. Almaty, Dayk-press Publ., 2007. 416 p. (in Russian).

    Králik Ľubor. Stručný etymologický slovník slovenčiny [Scientific etymological dictionary of the Slovak language]. Bratislava, VEDA Publ., 2015. 704 p. (in Slovak).

    Litvina, Anna Feliksovna; Uspenskiy, Fyodor Borisovich. Vybor imeni u russkikh knyazey Х–XVI vv. Dinasticheskaya istoriya skvoz’ prizmu antroponimiki [The Choice of the Name of the Russian Princes of the 10th–16th   centuries. Dynastic History through the Prism of Anthroponymics]. Moscow, Indrik Publ.,  2006. 904 p. (in Russian).

    Máčala, Pavol. Etnogeneza Slovanov v archeológii [Ethnogenesis of the Slavs in Archaeology]. Košice, Slovo Publ., 1995. 96 p. (in Slovak).

    Malinovská, Nora. Geographical concepts of Sclavinia in historical sources from the sixth to the fourteenth century, with an emphasis on the Moravian-Pannonian and South Slavic tradition, in Homza, Martin; Lukačka, Ján; Budak, Neven;Kucharská, Veronika; Kuzmová, Stanislava; Mesiarkin,Adam(eds.). Slovakiaand Croatia. Historical parallels and connections (until 1780).Bratislava; Zagreb: Department of Slovak history, Faculty of  Philosophy of the Comenius University,  Bratislava; Faculty of  Philosophy of Zagreb University Press, 2013. P. 60–65.

    Malinovská, Nora. Vývoj koncepcie Sclavinia v 12. storočí a jej reflexia v poľskej kronike Galla Anonyma [Evolution of the concept of Sclavinia in the 12th century and its reflection in the Chronicle by Gallus Anonimus], in Nové historické rozhľady. 2015. Vol. 5. No. 1. P. 43–53 (in Slovak).

    Mašek, Michal; Sommer, Petr; Žemlička, Josef; et al. Vladislav II.: druhý král z Přemyslova rodu: k 850. výročí jeho korunovace [Vladislav II: The second king from the Přemyslid dynasty: To the 850th anniversary of his coronation]. Praha, Lidové noviny Publ., 2009. 259 p. (in Czech).

    Mesiarkin, Adam. Examining the Slavic identity in Middle Ages, in Studia Ceranea. Lodź: Ceraneum. 2013. Vol. 3. P. 83–100.

    Mesiarkin, Adam. The Basis of Research into Croatian and Slovak Ethnogenesis, in  Homza, Martin; Lukačka, Ján; Budak, Neven; Kucharská, Veronika; Kuzmová, Stanislava; Mesiarkin,Adam(eds.). Slovakiaand Croatia. Historical parallels and connections (until 1780).Bratislava; Zagreb: Department of Slovak history, Faculty of  Philosophy of the Comenius University,  Bratislava; Faculty of  Philosophy of Zagreb University, 2013.  P. 38–42.

    Mesiarkin, Adam. Veča príspevok k dejinám slovanského práva [Some Notes on the History of the Slovak Law], in Historický časopis. 2016. Vol. 64. No. 2. P. 333–360 (in Slovak).

    Montinaro, Federico. Byzantium and the Slavs in the Reign of Justinian: Comparing the Two Recensions of Procopius’s Buildings, in Ivanišević, Vujadin; Kazanski, Michel (eds). The Pontic-Danubian Realm in the Period of the Great Migration. Paris; Belgrade: Peeters Publ., 2011. P. 89–114.

    Plassmann, Alheydis. Origo gentis: Identitäts und Legitimitätsstiftung in früh- und hochmittelalterlichen Herkunfterzählungen [Origo gentis: Identity and Legitimacy Foundation in Early and High Medieval Age Origin Stories]. Berlin, Akademie Publ.,  2006. 458 p. (in German).

    Podolan, Peter. Aspekty slovenskej historiografie generácie Jána Kollára a Pavla Jozefa Šafárika [Aspects of the Slovak Historiography in the Generation of Ján Kollár anda Pavol Jozef Šafárik], in Forum Historiae. 2007. Vol. 1. P. 1–13 (in Slovak).

    Podolan, Peter. Odkaz Jána Kollára slovenskej historiografii [Ján Kollár’s Behest for the Slovak Historiography], inHistoria Nova. Vol. II: Štúdie k jubileu Pavla Jozefa Šafárika. Bratislava, 2011. Vol. 5. P. 43–51.

    Pohl, Walter. Die Awaren: ein Steppenvolk in Mitteleuropa, 567–822 n. Chr. [The Avars: A steppe people in Central Europe, 567–822 A.D.]. München, Beck Publ., 1988. 553 p. (in German).

    Pohl, Walter. Telling the difference: Signs of ethnic identityin Noble, Thomas F. X. (ed.) From Roman Provinces to Medieval Kingdoms. London; New York: Routledge, 2006. P.99–138.

    Pohl, Walter. Początki Słowian: Kilka spostrzeżeń historicznych [Origins of the Slavs: Some Historical Notes], in  Urbańczyk, Przemysław (ed.). Nie-Słowianie o początkach Słowian. Poznań, Poznańskie Towarzystwo Przyjaciół Nauk Publ., 2006. P. 11–27 (in Polish).

    Pohl, Walter. Staat und Herrschaft im frühen Mittelalter: Überlegung zum Forschungstand [State and Lordship in the Early Middle Ages: Reflection on the state of research], in Stuart, Airlie; Pohl, Walter; Reimitz, Helmut (eds.). Staat im frühen Mittelalter. Wien, Austrian Academy of Sciences Publ., 2006. P. 9–38 (in German).

    Pritsak, Omeljan. The Slavs and the Avars, in Settimane di studio del centro italiano di studi sull’alto medioevo. Vol. XXX: Gli Slavi occidentali e meridionali nell’alto medioevo [Week studies of the Italian center for early medieval studies, vol. XXX: Western and Southern Slavs in the early Middle Ages], Spoleto, Centrodi Studio del Centro Italiano di Studi sull’ alto Medioevo Publ., 1983. P. 353–435.

    Smith, David Anthony. Myths and memories of the nation. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999. 288 p.

    Sverdlov, Мikhail Borisovich. K istorii velikomoravskoy kul’turnoy traditsii na Rusi kontsa XI – nachala XII v. [To the history of Great Moravian cultural tradition in Rus’ at the end of the 11th and the beginning of the 12th centuries], in Peterburgskiy istoricheskiy zhurnal. 2015. Vol. 7. No. 3. P. 10–21 (in Russian).

    Timura, Viktor. Zamlčané dejiny: Pôvod a začiatky Slovenov-Slovákov [Ignored History: The origin and beginnings of the Slavs-Slovaks]. Bratislava, Eko-konzult Publ., 2015. 504 p. (in Slovak).

    Toporov, Vladimir Nikolaevich. Svyatost’ i svyatye v russkoy dukhovnoy kul’ture. Vol. I: Pervyy vek khristianstva na Rusi [Holiness and saints in Russian spiritual culture. Vol. I: The first century of Christianity in Rus’]. Moscow, Yazyki russkoy kul’tury, 1995. 873 p. (in Russian).

    Tyszkiewicz, Lech. Koczownicy turecko-mongolscy a migracje Słowian [Turkic-Mongol nomads and Migrations of the Slavs], in  Salamon, Maciej; Strzelczyk, Jerzy (eds.). Wedrówka i etnogeneza w staroźytności i w średniowieczu [Migration and Ethnogenesis in the Antiqity and Middle Ages]. Kraków: Historia Iagellonica, 2004. P. 190–210 (in Polish).

    Urbańczyk, Przemysław. Władza i polityka we wczesnym średniowieczu [Power and Policy in the Early Middle Ages]. Wrocław, Wrocław University Publ., 2000. 280 p. (in Polish).

    Urbańczyk, Przemysław. Co się stało w 965 roku? [What happened in 966?]. Poznań, Zysk i S-ka Publ., 2016. 168 p. (in Polish).

    Váňa, Zdeněk. Svět dávných Slovanů [World of the Ancient Slavs]. Praha, Artia Publ., 1983. 239 p. (in Czech).

    Verešová, Nora. Vývoj chápania geografického termínu Sklavínia v historických prameňoch 6.–14. storočia [Evolution of the notion of the geographical term Sclavinia in the 6th to 14th century sources], in Historický zborník. Martin: Matica slovenská, 2008. No. 1. P. 124–143 (in Slovak).

    Verešová,Nora. Povesť vremennych let a jej koncepcia Slovienskoj zemli[The Tale of Bygone Years and its concept of the slavic land], inHistoria Nova. Vol. II: Štúdie k jubileu Pavla Jozefa Šafárika. Bratislava, 2011. P. 12–20(in Slovak).

    Wenskus, Reinhard. Stammesbildung und Verfassung. Das Werden der frühmittelalterlichen gentes [Tribal formation and political organization. The making of early medieval gentes]. Köln; Graz: Böhlau Verlag, 1961. 656 p. (in German).

    Wihoda, Martin. První česká království [First Czech kingdom]. Praha, Lidové noviny Publ., 2015. 440 p. (in Czech).

    Wolfram, Herwig. Around the Year 1000, in Urbanczyk, Przemysław (ed.). Europa around the Year 1000. Warszawa, DiG Publ., 2001. P. 395–399.

    Wolfram, Herwig. Origo et religio. Ethnic traditions and literature in early medieval texts, in Noble, Thomas F. X. (ed.) From Roman Provinces to Medieval Kingdoms. London; New York: Routledge, 2006. P. 57–74. 

    Wolfram H. Terminologisches [Terminology], in Ludwig, Uwe; Schilp, Thomas (eds). Nomen und Fraternitas: Festschrift für Dieter Geuenich zum 65. Geburtstag. Berlin; Boston, 2008. Berlin; New York, 2009. P. 787–802 (in German).

    Wolfram, Herwig. Conversio Bagoariorum et Carantanorum: Das Weißbuch der Salzburger Kirche über die erfolgreiche Mission in Karantanien und Pannonien mit Zusättzen und Erganzungen [Conversio Bagoariorum et Carantanorum: The White Book of the Salzburg Church on the Successful Mission in Carantania and Pannonia with Additions and Supplements]. Ljubljana, Hermagoras Publ., 2012. 419 p. (in German).

 

Print Email

  • Hits: 450